American Idol How do te decide how to vote?

harold posted on Mar 20, 2008 at 07:42AM
After tonight's shocker, and remembering astonishing results in the past, I realize that I may have very different criteria for who should win "American Idol" than the majority of voters. So I asked three separate pick questions, for the primary, secondary and tertiary factors you consider when you vote for a contestant. If there was a way to create a pick that let you choose multiple answers, I'd do it. But as we can't, I made three separate ones. They're here:

link
link
link

When answering these questions, please make sure to choose different picks for each. Thanks!

American Idol 10 risposte

Click here to write a response...
più di un anno fa ineedcoffee said…
first is talent
second is performance
third is growth or lack of
these are my three key factors in judging.
più di un anno fa I_love_Simon said…
Based on whoever has the best voice! (Duh!)
If you can't figure it out on your own, listen to Simon.
più di un anno fa gosselinfan626 said…
-voice(obviously)
-individuality
-performance as a whole
last edited più di un anno fa
più di un anno fa chrisy018 said…
Pick a favorite and always support them!

più di un anno fa Mindfreak666 said…
I agree with Chrisy. Even if my favorite has a bad night I will still continue to vote for them. You can't give up because of one bad performance. I try to pick the person that I think has a great voice but no necessarily the best. They also have to have charisma and be a good performer. I also look for personality...they have to stand out.
più di un anno fa BOOBOOWORM said…
kiss

I FOUND SOME GOOD INFO ABOUT AN AMERICAN IDOL PARTY WITH WINNERS AND CONTESTANTS FROM ALL THE SEASONS IN THE PAST!!!!

CHECK OUT THIS GREAT VIDEO

link
link
link
link
più di un anno fa LibbyLolli said…
i vote based on voice and creativity
più di un anno fa r-pattz said…
obviously talent. and how they change the song to fit them.
più di un anno fa judesmommy said…
smile
1. voice and talent
2. stage charisma and performances
3. creativity and how far they've come from the beginning
più di un anno fa purpleman said…
Check out the latest interview to come out of the show American Idol featuring the two finalists and Ryan Seacrest @ link