rispondi a questa domanda

Principesse Disney Domanda

To those of te complaining about Naomi Scott being cast as gelsomino because she's half-Indian and "isn't Arab"

I don't see y'all complaining about gelsomino being voiced da a full-on Caucasian in the original. o her Canto voice being done da a Filipino.
What's the problem here? Because I don't see any.
 hatelarxene posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Principesse Disney Risposte

quishy11 said:
I can't even believe people have problems with this. It doesn't matter what race she is o what country she's from, it matters if she looks like gelsomino and is a good actor and can play a good role. Social justice warriors are sad.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
uploaded900 said:
Dude give it a rest. This is some successivo level pettiness.
No one says anything about Jasmine's voice attrici is because they just provide the VOICE for the character, they don't see Linda Larkin o Lea Salonga's face to represent the Middle Eastern character. I don't give a rat's culo if someone of a different race provides the speaking/singing voice of a character. They found an Arab actor for Aladdin, so I don't see why they couldn't find one for Jasmine.

BTW I'm not even that pissed off about Naomi Scott having the role. I just would of rather seen a better representative. te seriously need to chill and accept that people are allowed to have opinions different from yours.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
best answer tbh
UnholyNoise posted più di un anno fa
wavesurf said:
People need to take chill pill, but "movie buffs" rarely do that.

I didn't vote in that poll. I'm ignoring this the way I should have ignored the furor over Beauty and The Beast, and the furor that people are making over the Mulan remake plot choices with Shang apparently missing in action.

I'm leaving it alone...and backing away.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Sparklefairy375 said:
gelsomino is a Middle Eastern, and Naomi, being an half-Indian and she is nothing look like Jasmine. Naomi looks più like an Caucasian rather than an Arabic/Indian (maybe it's kind of whitewashing). It's kind of strange if gelsomino was played da someone who was not Arab while Aladdin was. Think about how strange if POC character has to be played da someone who was half-Caucasian.

And what's the correlation about Naomi being complained to be not Arab with animated Jasmine's voice actresses? They don't see their races for voicing an animated character, all they need is a good voice. Voice actress works behind the screen so it doesn't really matter if she has different race. But the live-action one being a problem as she works front the camera.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
UnholyNoise said:
>asks question
>not actually interested in receiving an answer
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
No. They just want an answer as to what is actually a problem rather than hearing più whining about nothing.
quishy11 posted più di un anno fa
next question »