Principesse Disney *Tiebreaker* DP Movie Accuracy Countdown: Pick which movie is LEAST accurate compared to its original fairytale. (Results based on comments.)

This question is now closed
30 fans picked:
La Bella e la Bestia
   53%
La bella addormentata
   47%
 MaidofOrleans posted più di un anno fa
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

8 comments

user photo
MaidofOrleans picked La bella addormentata:
Same arguments as I've been using for the past several rounds.

To those who were concerned by the fact that this movie is based off of Perrault's version of the tale, yes I am aware of that. However this countdown is about comparing the DP movies to the ORIGINAL versions of the fairytales, not necessarily the versions that they were directly based off of. I'd rather not change the rules on everyone halfway through the countdown, so I'd like to keep it that way.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Jayden-G picked La Bella e la Bestia:
Well this one is different from the original in a lot of ways. One is that they had no talking objects, no Gaston, and no angry Beast. He was extremely kind to her. Maurice got captured because Belle asked him for a rose, he was rich, had sisters, and had little to no plot.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Beastlysoul25 picked La bella addormentata:
I've been saying the same thing what MaidofOrleans is saying!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
ppgcowgirl picked La bella addormentata:
She popped out two kids. I think that makes all other arguments invalid XD
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Swanpride picked La Bella e la Bestia:
@MaidofOrleans The Perrault version is the one with the twins. It's the Grimm version which ends with her waking up, because they consider the second part of the fairy tale as part of another story. So it's questionable which one is the "original" version.
I first wanted to pick it nevertheless because, well, giant dragon, but Jayden-G is right, no talking objects, no rival, two sisters, no battle at the castle....there are more new elements in it, and they are both very close to the original meaning.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
BelleAnastasia picked La Bella e la Bestia:
This is hard. Both have similarities and differences from the original tales. I'm choosing BATB, because it just seems to have more differences than Sleeping Beauty.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
rhythmicmagic picked La Bella e la Bestia:
What I said before- mostly about the Beast being nice to her.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
BraBrief picked La Bella e la Bestia:
I think Sleeping Beauty is similar, except for some little things.
posted più di un anno fa.