rispondi a questa domanda

Harry Potter vs Twilight Domanda

For Everyone!

If you're solely an HP fan, what are some things that could be changed about Twilight (anything to do with it, not just the books) that would make te like it? o at the very least tolerate it? If you're an HP fan and te like Twilight, please state something about Twilight that te wished was different.

If you're solely a Twilight fan, what things could be changed about HP that would make te like it, o make te tolerant of it? As I mentioned in the HP section, if te like HP too, simply state something about HP that te wish was different.

Just basically: Are there things that could be done that would make te like the other series? Amore it, even? Tell me, peeps! :)

LadyLilith♥
 LadyLilith posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight Risposte

bri-marie said:
I'm a Harry Potter fan. The things I would have changed about Twilight are:

1) The writting. Every descrizione of Edward and all the other "hotties" did not need three, four, eight modifiers.

2) Relatability. I don't just mean the, "She's in Amore with a vampire and shapeshifter" stuff. I can't relate to walking into a new school and having everyone fall all over me. Especially if I was being described as "plain". Also, in my high school, we have cliques, and they don't all get along together. And everyone knows it.

3) The Volturi would have actually done something. They would have earned the right to be "scary."

4) The characters would have flaws. And developed.

4) Not all the Vampiri#From Dracula to Buffy... and all creatures of the night in between. and shapeshifters would have looked like gods. They would have had weaknesses (like burned da silver, o something).

5) There would have been a battle, and poeple would have gotten hurt and died.

6) Nessie. I'm not sure if I would have taken her out entirely, but I hate what Smeyer did with her.

7) No imprinting.

8)Background characters would not have just been dropped after the wedding. They also would have had a point throughout the series.

9) The plots would have all fit together. There would be less plot holes, the impossible things (if I kept any) would have been explained in a way that makes sense. Medical facts would be true/add up.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
lemony44 said:
Ok. believe it o not, I actually think TW isn't that bad, I actually quite enjoyed Leggere it. But when I found out they were comparing it to Harry Potter, I was pissed. A LOT!So if they stopped, I would stop.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Ah, so te just want all of this nonsense to go away, eh?
LadyLilith posted più di un anno fa
*
nonsence is kool
MrsRadcliffe posted più di un anno fa
*
Yeah me too! my mom showed me a news articolo about twilight being "the new Harry Potter" I turned obsessive anti.
TheQuibbler posted più di un anno fa
ilovereading said:
HP fan. :)

What would I change about Twilight:
1.The writing
It should sound less like purple prose. And there is definitely too much of Bella`s descriptions of Edward (white pale, granite like, etc.). If Meyer wanted to stress her love, she should at least change viewpoint più often o tell some parts of the story in third person. That way, we would get the whole Bella-loves-Edward idea when we were Leggere her story, but it wouldn`t be all about it.

2.Plot
The Volturi would be introduced in the first book and there should be più about their background. Not to mention the big fight in the end (the good guys would win ofcourse, but somebody would need to sacrifice). Also, some hints of the licantropi in the first book wouldn`t hurt. I know Jacob told the legend, but it should be something più solid.
And the plot holes? Less of them.

3.Characters
Bella is the main character. And yet, we don`t know much about her before she moved to Forks. She doesn`t have any hobies, any old Friends o ex-boyfriends (althougt every guy on new shool likes her), not to mention any relatives besides her mother and father (grandparents, uncles and aunts, cousins...). She would be stronger as female and not longing to be pushed around da Edward. o it shouldn`t be showed as it is a good thing.
Other character should be developed to. Stories of the Cullen family were my favourite parts, but humans didn`t have anything like it.

4.Vampires
It`s not about the sparkling (ok, it is about sparkling), but they should have a weak spot, and not just licantropi that can rip them apart and burn them, something a human can preform (cross, garlic, sun, I don`t really care, as long as it`s something).

Because the basic story isn`t bad. Girl falls inlove with a vampire, with all the troubles that he brings. Twiligt didn`t use the potential of the idea.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
This is a bit longer than I originaly planed. :)
ilovereading posted più di un anno fa
Ash24 said:
Im a hp fan and what i would change in twilight Film would be the actors, i reckon if they spent più time finding suitable actors for the respected parts i think twilight Film would have been better, the twilight libri were amazing just the Film dont do it any justice.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
chagrin91 said:
Harry should have dies no.1
Ginny was never supposed to be harry;s girlfriend o wife i hate her no.2
The seventh book should have been written much better no.3
Everything shouldn't have happened in the last two pages no.4
Harry should learn other spells then expelliamus.




he used this one spell through out the seventh book man te should learn other spells too it is not the only spell in the world i mean he is standing in front of voldemort going to fight him and the spell he uses is expelaimus very clever
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
mind me if i dont know the spelling of te spell
chagrin91 posted più di un anno fa
*
^ Yeah
venvargie posted più di un anno fa
*
"everything shouldn't have happened in the last two pages no.4 " um....last time I checked, the whole final showdown took place over several CHAPTERS, not the last 2 pages...
souflizzle317 posted più di un anno fa
TeamSiriusBlack said:
The fighting. In the third book, a few Cullens/ Lupi would die. In the fourth book, I would make them fight, and the Cullens lose ^_^
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »