rispondi a questa domanda

Harry Potter vs Twilight Domanda

dibattito Challenge

This is a challenge for both HP and Twilight fans.

The challenge is as follows:

dato the statement, "Bella cigno is bland and has no personality",the challenge is, if you're a Twilight fan, defend [agree with]that statement, and if you're a Harry Potter fan, oppose that statement[defending Bella], using your best debating skills.

Remember, this is a dibattito challenge, the point is that your argument should NOT reflect your personal views!
 KateKicksAss posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight Risposte

Diasasis said:
Agree
Considering that this a book being told through her own eyes, it's hard to believe that it'd come off as being bland, and yet, Bella cigno seems to get Lost in translation. It'd be understandable, perhaps, if in a third-person persective Bella came off with little personality, maybe she's just shy o not all that interested in those around her. However, one would think that being told through her own perspective, Bella would come off as più of a dynamic character, not so. Alot of Bella's perceived personality traits are demonstrated through telling rather than showing. She talks about being an "old soul" and yet as soon as she arrives in Forks she becomes a rather cliche love-sick teenager. She's clumsy, not really a personality trait.
We never really get deep into what makes Bella, Bella and that's really what makes her come off as being bland. Throughout the entire series her sole focus is on Edward, occasionally drifting to the likes of Jacob and her father, but only in extreme circumstances, like when their lives are at risk. There's just no real insight into what makes Bella tick other than Edward, take him away and what do te get? Several months of blank pages.

Probably not the expert dibattito te were looking for but I answered anyways.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Nice answer :)
Ms_Mea posted più di un anno fa
cassie-1-2-3 said:
Bella could have put più effort into being a più typical teenager, since she didn't particularly enjoy being different, o on a different brain wave frequency, as she put it. If she wanted to be più accepted da everyone, she should have been più outgoing and interact with più people instead of staying at home Leggere and studying, which is honestly not very entertaining o personality defining to someone not residing in your own mind.

Not making a huge effort to stand out will project itself in that precise way. If te present yourself as bland (not worthy of attention), te will be seen as bland. If te don't express your personality, it will look as if te have none to express.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
ladywyze said:
Agree.
Bella's an idiot.
*bow*
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Win :)
Lunalovely posted più di un anno fa
lucius_malloy said:
I disagree.
I think Bella is actually very interesting and a had a complex personality, which is merely hidden under all the layers of shit she has to go through each day. I mean, her dad needs as much care as your average four-year-old, her Friends are such a randomly put-together lot that she's continuously having to keep the peace between them, not to mention the fact that her intelligence is above average, so te need to factor in all the pressure and such that stem from that.
And let's not forget the fact that though she thought she'd finally found happiness with Edward, her old childhood friend just had to reappear and develop a very impractical crush on her.
So it's fair to say that she has a lot on her hands at the moment. (Did I mention her boyfriend sparkles? Imagine the difficulties that must pose in public).

This all being said, I'm certain that if Bella were allowed to let her hair down every once in a while, the bright, cheery personality we all know to be there would mostra itself some more, make its presence known to others than just myself.

(is that what te were looking for?)
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Kind of, I was basically just trying to see if people could see both sides of the issue, and also just practice debating, :P
KateKicksAss posted più di un anno fa
Prawls8612 said:
Agree.
Shes boring, hardly has personality, and is not really that funny. In the Film she is always blinking to much and it really gets annoying. She could do way better at playing the roll of a teenager and maybe add some spunk to the caracter. Anyone else could have done a waayyy better job.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »