What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry Potter vs Twilight In your opinion, which respective fandom fan are più mature?

42 fans picked:
Harry Potter fan
Harry Potter fan
   40%
None. Both are equally immature
None. Both are equally immature
   31%
None. Both are pretty mature.
None. Both are pretty mature.
   17%
Twilight fan
Twilight fan
   12%
 cuteypuffgirl posted più di un anno fa
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

21 comments

user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
cassie-1-2-3 picked None. Both are equally immature:
They are all the same.

Some people like Harry Potter, some people don't.
Some people can handle that, some people can't. (It works both ways)
Some people like Twilight, some people don't.
Some people can handle that, some people can't. (It works both ways)

Nobody here is superior.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are pretty mature.
zanhar1 picked None. Both are pretty mature.:
On their own spots everyones pretty mature. This spot is where things tend to get crazy.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
goodtimes picked None. Both are equally immature:
Are you trying to take away from the point I was making by getting a bunch of Harry Potter fans to say they're better than everyone else?

I like Harry Potter and Twilight and I can remove myself enough to see how disgusting you all can behave. These Harry Potter fan cyber attacks are just as bad as the Twilight fan physical attack you people like to bring up to say Twilight fans are unstable. They might be even worse because a physical attack only lasts for a moment, but an online attack can last for days because you can take breaks to eat and sleep, then start right back up where you left off the next day.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are pretty mature.
zanhar1 picked None. Both are pretty mature.:
I never said anything of the sort. On these kinds of picks I usually pick the both option I think Harry potter is a better book then Twilight. I see the fandoms as equals. I was trying to say something that does erupt into another fight make what you will of it. I behave disgustingly, yeah thanks. Twilight fans cyber attack Hp fans too you know if you were here in the beginning you would've seen it. It works both ways. And I personally believe physical attacks are worse but that's just me. I personally when cyber attacked log off forget about it come across it again and repeat the cycle til we come to a peaceful conclusion.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
goodtimes picked None. Both are equally immature:
I didn't say anything to you.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are pretty mature.
zanhar1 picked None. Both are pretty mature.:
Are YOU trying to take away from the point I was making by getting a bunch of Harry Potter fans to say they're better than everyone else?

I like Harry Potter and Twilight and I can remove myself enough to see how disgusting YOU all can behave. These Harry Potter fan cyber attacks are just as bad as the Twilight fan physical attack YOU people like to bring up to say Twilight fans are unstable. They might be even worse because a physical attack only lasts for a moment, but an online attack can last for days because you can take breaks to eat and sleep, then start right back up where YOU left off the next day

I capitalized all the times you said you. The word you is often used to indicate something directed at the person you're talking too. Unless I'm interpeting that wrong too.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
goodtimes picked None. Both are equally immature:
I wasn't talking to you. We posted our comments at the same time, or within less than a minute of each other. It would be physically impossible for me to read your comment then type all that in less than a minute. I'm not a world champion speed typist. Your comment wasn't there when I started typing, it's not always about you. I've noticed you do that a lot. Next time, if someone's comment doesn't make any sense in relation to you, and if it makes more since in relation to someone above you or the person who posted the content, it's okay to assume the person isn't talking to you.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
goodtimes picked None. Both are equally immature:
Look, it took me 10 minutes to type just that.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are pretty mature.
zanhar1 picked None. Both are pretty mature.:
I did make sense to me! I said noone was immature and in a sense that can take away from the point. Who exactly were you talking to then? I was the only one commenting or were you talking to everyone as a whole. Or were you talking to Cassie I don't see how she's taking away from your point either. I'm a pessimist I always assume the worst. And I am paranoid (don't believe me I'll find a past comment in which I said so) I do this on real life too; if someone is laughing even if I just walk into the room I'll think they are laughing at me. If someone says something bad and I am sitting near them I think they are talking about me.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
goodtimes picked None. Both are equally immature:
I'm talking to the person who asked the question.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are pretty mature.
zanhar1 picked None. Both are pretty mature.:
I didn't see that coming at all. Unless the question was something biased I usually don't see people questioning the asker.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
bri-marie picked None. Both are equally immature:
I have yet to come across a fandom with large amounts of mature fans. Majority of fans in any fandom (Harry Potter included) are immature.

Personally, I think if someone picks "Harry Potter fans are more mature" or "Twilight fans are more mature" they're just proving my point.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
Lackson4ever85 picked None. Both are equally immature:
both is pretty childish really.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
mandali picked None. Both are equally immature:
Both the series have their own Black sheep
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
VampiresRevenge picked None. Both are equally immature:
I wonder why the people who picked "Harry Potter fans" or "Twilight fans" haven't commented...
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are pretty mature.
ClaireVoyant picked None. Both are pretty mature.:
*sarcasm*
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
I don't agree with any of these answers. You can't judge a Fandom as a whole. I mean, all fandoms have their mature and immature fans.....no fandom is better than another, and you also can't stereotype like this and say a WHOLE FANDOM is mature or immature.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Harry Potter fan
luv_warriorcatz picked Harry Potter fan:
While I won't say that all twilight fans are immature and hp fans aren't because that's not true, I tend to see more immaturity on the twilight side that the harry potter side. Of course, hp fans has their many moments.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are equall- y...
VampiresRevenge picked None. Both are equally immature:
^ It depends on how you look at it. If you choose to see yourself on the HP side (or Twilight), you will naturally see more people on the other side who act "immaturely." If you looked at both sides without bias, you would see that both have their immature tendencies and basically the same amount of them.

And just because you see a few Twilight fans acting more immature than HP fans, that doesn't make the whole fandom act the way those few fans do.
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
Twilight fan
mr-cullen picked Twilight fan:
oh please..........they dont choose albus over renesmee
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
None. Both are pretty mature.
zanhar1 picked None. Both are pretty mature.:
^ That was sarcasm right?
posted più di un anno fa.