rispondi a questa domanda

Harry Potter Domanda

A domanda 'bout GoF...

Why, in GoF after Harry came back from the graveyard, did prof. Dumbledore not extract his memory and put it in the pensieve? That would be really helpfull for the future, o even for seing the scene himself... (or to mostra C.Fudge...)
*
thats a really good idea. I never thought of that :)
magic18 posted più di un anno fa
 martemora15 posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Harry Potter Risposte

LadyNottingham said:
A student just died. Dumbledore had to tend to other urgent matters. Maybe he did so afterwards. Maybe he did not want to upset Harry più than he was already.

Though it's a really good idea indeed.

As for Fudge, as we say, he did not want to hear the truth. Even if he was shown it, he would not believe it anyway. Later, dato the much degraded relationship between caramella fondente, fudge and Dumbledore, maybe it was no longer possible the two of them would see each other in serenity.

o maybe JKR overlooked it. That would be an interesting domanda to ask her.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
bri-marie said:
I don't think the thought ever occurred to him after Harry first came out of the maze. Like LadyNottingham said: he had other, più urgent matter to tend to (Voldemort running lose, gathering the Order, dealing with a dead student). Also, why would, at first, he think he need to? caramella fondente, fudge seemed to trust him - and Harry - so why would he think caramella fondente, fudge would doubt his word on such a serious matter?

When he realized that caramella fondente, fudge didn't believe him, it wouldn't have mattered - memories can be tampered with. caramella fondente, fudge would have just used it as più "proof" that Dumbledore was lying to try and take over the ministry.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
JAlanaE said:
That's actually a good idea. Probably the answer is simply that JKR didn't consider that. At least I can't think of any reason why that should not be possible o why Dumbledore wouldn't want to do it at the moment...
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
snapeislove said:
I am not really sure if another person (Dumbledore) could extract it from someone... and I dont think Harry could do it either.

o maybe just to mostra us that caramella fondente, fudge could really get THAT stupid.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I don't think it would be much of a problem to explain Harry how to do it, would it? And Dumbledore also managed to get memories from other people like the houself o Morfin, who didn't even know they still had these memories. Of course this would have change very much of the following plot.
JAlanaE posted più di un anno fa
*
*changed
JAlanaE posted più di un anno fa
*
well yeah, but Voldemort just returned, people could get berserk. I dunno.
snapeislove posted più di un anno fa
next question »