I LOVE FIRESTAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i dont like tigerstar as an adult, bit when he was a kit, he was the most loyal, nicest, cutest kit ever! its all Thistleclaw's (his mentor) fault he is evil!

I think tigerstars picture has longtail's wound on the ear!

I love the warrior series and firestar who couldn't?

that wound isnt from longtail its from a random warrior in another clan probaby RiveClan
hint
hint
Oakheart

omg! tigerstar is so much awesomer than any warrior cat! u guys r crazy not to pick him!
sure he had a bit of anger problems, but dont we all at some point?

I LOVE FIRESTAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TIGERstar is OK!!

i hate tigerstar he made blackfoot and darkstripe kill stonefur an he lured a pack f dogs in to thunderclan camp and he killed rinningwind and redtail AND he set a trap for bluestar, instead cinderpelt went into his trap now all cause of him she was never made a warrior:,( AND he made the dogs kill swiftpaw and make brightheart loose half of her face and probably other stuff i did not even mention and if firestar never came to the forest, tigerstar would be leader of thunderclan and darkstripe would be deputy. :( firestar also killed scourge but im also glad that scourge killed tigerstar >:)

I liek Tigerstar

I <3 Firestar! Tigerstar tried to kill him!!!! Grrr!

Tigerstar may be insane but you have to amit hes one awesome persisent asshole he just keeps trying even after he died

firestar is awesome!!!!!!!!! tigerstar is so evil. he even tried to kill firestar and take over the clans while he was dead in the dark forest! he broke the warrior code without reason so many times. also, until he came in the dark forest, the dark forest cats walked alone.....he even broke the rules in the dark forest!

I HATE FIRESTAR! HES A ANNOYING AND A LITTLE GOODY-TWO-PAWS(lol)!
but i had to choose him because tigerstars evil

Look tigerstar was evil, he was mean, and he did have some problems, BUT! he was very intelligent in doing all he did, gaining cats trust, working his way up, and nearly killing bluestar, so tigerstar wins for me.

I know, it's all Tristleclaw's fault!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If he wasn't alive, tigerstar would be
so nice, and very .... the best!

Who the hell is thistleclaw?!??!!?

Thistleclaw was Tigerstars mentor when he was an apprentice. Read Bluestars Prophecy. :)

or read rise or scourge :)

i prefer Leafpool :)

I prefer Firestar.

I don't get how people hate him~

We all have different opinions c: but yea as some people said, I liked Tigerstar as a kit but then his mentor turned him bad. So I chose Firestar..

anyone who picks firestar is crazy! he kills ALL of the good cats.

I like Firestar,but personally,I think Tigerstar is way better.It wasn't his fualt that he became the way he is.(But,I think that's why I like him...)Blame Thistleclaw.

firestar is more waesome then tigerstar cuz tigerstar tried to kill ravenpaw

i hate firestar. he kills scourge, the most awesome cat in the whole sereis and on top of that he's just a huge bore. i wish he would just die already!

I love firestar he is awsome!!! <3

My kin is Tigerstar, so of course I hate Firestar, go Bramblestar!

Its all thistleclaw's fault that tigerstar turned bad ;(.

Firestar does die. In the last series

it was a hard desision but i asked my friends and they said to pick firestar so i did ^-^

Oh ravenpawx has a point about tigerstar cause ravenpaw is the most epicest cat in the whole series

What in the world is wrong with Tigerstar?This isnt to be rudebut you choose Firestar becasue hes the main character and hes not cruel.Whats wrong with tigerstar?Tigerstar this or Tigerstar that.Im not a main-charater person if you now what i mean.

Tigerstar dose have a point of being half clan.Clans cant have divided loyaltes.But he dosent need to kill them.

Ive always liked the bad guys more. And come on Firestar is a kittypet.

*sigh* Wish I was with him...

If I don't choose Tigerstar he'll claw me up. (HELP! Tigerstar has me!!!)