What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

C’era una volta In the season 1 finale, there was originally a line where Emma asked Regina if she killed Graham, but it ended up being cut. Thoughts?

42 fans picked:
What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?
What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?
   67%
Who cares?
Who cares?
   17%
I&# 39; m glad they did. It should come up later.
I'm glad they did. It should come up later.
   17%
(added by minervadawn)
 afirewiel posted più di un anno fa
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

22 comments

user photo
I&# 39; m glad they did. It should...
afirewiel picked I'm glad they did. It should come up later.:
I personally am hoping that they cut it because they want Emma to realize it later and in a much bigger way.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
I&# 39; m glad they did. It should...
minervadawn picked I'm glad they did. It should come up later.:
@afirewiel I was just going to post a similar comment. Personally I would have been disappointed if grahams murder had been recognized in a single line. He deserves more then that.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
Princess-Yvonne picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
I agree with the above statements!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Who cares?
zanhar1 picked Who cares?:
At this point I don't care either way around, Regina isn't going to get a happy ending anyhow so why not?
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
claudia_bb picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
time for justice!

God, he was so hot & a sweet guy
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Who cares?
magichand picked Who cares?:
RUMPELSTILTSKIN KILLED MANY PEOPLE.

I DON'T SEE ANY JUSTICE THERE.

REGINA ISN'T ONLY DEVIL IN THIS TOWN.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
claudia_bb picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
^You don't care about Graham and he's death. I get it.

I don't care about gina.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Who cares?
zanhar1 picked Who cares?:
@magichand Exactly, Rumple can do whatever he wants, kill whoever he wants and can get away with it. But heaven forbid, if Regina does people practically say she needs to burn in Hell.

@Claudia She never said she didn't care about Graham's death. Picking 'who cares' doesn't mean she doesn't care about Graham's death, it simply means she doesn't care if Emma finds out. I care abut Graham's death, he was cool. I just don't care weather or not Emma knows about his manner of death.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
Princess-Yvonne picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
Most of gina's fans are so envious on all the love Rumps gets. On the fact that he has more fans.

ever thought that... It's maybe because Rumps is a more complex, interesting, fascinating etc. character than gina?

Oh, no.. I suppose is easier to see dearies as stupid fans who can't make a difference between one evil character and another.

sheesh! how disrespectful.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Who cares?
zanhar1 picked Who cares?:
It's not envy, at least not for me. It's annoyance, I am annoyed by the hypocrisy and the double standards. Why is it that most of Gina's fans can admit that Gina ripping hearts out is just as sick as Rumple doing so and some of Rumple's fans cannot? I hate unfair double standards.

No I haven't I have always thought it was a bias. Generally it is. Biases aside, they are both very complex, deep, and interesting characters. And in my opinion to say otherwise is an insult to our brilliant writers of Once.

No one ever said anything about dearies being stupid, I don't know where you got that from? Just because a person prefers one villain over an other doesn't make them stupid. How disrespectful to assume some of us are that shallow.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
Princess-Yvonne picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
@zanhar1 you are constantly insulting my intelligence. I'm frankly sick and tired to explain the differences, the subtleties that make me like one villain and dislike another.

It's like pointless... you're stuck on your idea: that a villain is a villain. all villains are the same. if I like one I must like all. if I don't like one I must dislike all.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Who cares?
PPPopopipop picked Who cares?:
To be honest, I don't think Graham will be mantioned in the show ever again... I liked him, but I somehow glad they didn't bring back the topic of his death in S1 finale. Now it would be kind of weird of they'd suddenly started talking about him after all this time & all things going on right now.
I think that Graham's death storyline was just buried under more important/current stuff...
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Who cares?
zanhar1 picked Who cares?:
@Yvonne Oh for crying out loud, how so? Not once have I ever called you stupid. If I questioned your intelligence, you defiantly questioned mine. Quit taking stuff so personally, just because I disagree with your opinions doesn't mean I think you're any less intelligent than anyone else. If you're sick of it then stop, don't respond to my responses. If you're that sick of it you'll just ignore my comments. If you don't want to explain yourself don't comment back with insults towards Regina or her fans respond by saying you don't care to explain yourself. Commenting back with an argument usually indicates that you want to have that same discussion. Frankly I will repeat myself as long as it takes because some people and I'm not talking about you in particular just don't understand certain points. And you may stop trying to make me look like the only mean one, you haven't exactly been the kindest either.

And where did you get that info from. You are not me, you do not know what ideals I hold, so stop pretending like you do. You don't know anything about me, I don't know anything about you. And if you wanted to know that's not true at all; I love many types of villains I have favored them since elementary school so I think I know that not all villains are the same. Some were born evil, some have dark histories that make them evil, some have some mental disorder that makes them evil. I think I understand that not all villains are the same. Oh and if this isn't an insult to my intelligent I don't know what is, so thank you so much for that.
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
I&# 39; m glad they did. It should...
afirewiel picked I'm glad they did. It should come up later.:
To say that Rumpel isn't having to pay for his crimes would be untrue. While the people of Storybrooke have pretty much left him alone, Rumpel's past is checking up with him in the form of Hook. Hook is making him pay. It may not be justice, but to say that Regina shouldn't have to pay for her crimes because Rumpel isn't would not only be unfair, but untrue.

Also, Graham receiving justice is very important. Rumpel finding his son, Belle getting her memory back, none of that is as nearly important. I don't care if it seems strange to just suddenly mention Graham after all this time. Graham was murdered, and to have his murderer continue to walk free while everyone else is oblivious to how he actually died, makes no sense.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
Princess-Yvonne picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
Then, @zanhar1 stop calling me a hypocrite and understand that appreciating a character does not mean justifying him/her. Stop calling me a hypocrite and understand there are good reasons not to like gina, and like Rumps. Stop insulting me.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
I&# 39; m glad they did. It should...
minervadawn picked I'm glad they did. It should come up later.:
@Princess-Yvonne. As a third party in the Evil Regal vs. Dearies war, I have to say that comment was a bit out of line and to use your worlds disrespectful. From where I stand you guys aren't all that different. Basically anything (negative or positive) that is said about Rumple can be said about Gina and vice versa. I'd challenge you and zanhar1 to make a list of all the thing that you like about Rumple (or Gina) and then compare them and see how many things line up. I think you'd be surprised.

I love Rumple and Gina because they are BOTH complex, interesting and fascinating characters. But neither of them are absolved of their crimes. They will both have to face the consequences sooner or later. Rumps is already paying for killing Milah with Hook and his vendetta and he'll pay for it again when Bae and Belle find out. Gina already lost Henry in part because of what she did to Graham and she'll pay again when Emma finds out eventually.

Edit: Okay... I started typing this just after Princess-Yvonne Posted her first comment and then left to deal with something and by the time i got back it had spiraled out of control and afirewiel had already said what I was trying to get at in the second bit of my comment.

I still think that if you two took up my challenge you'd find that you weren't quite as different as you seem to think.
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
Who cares?
zanhar1 picked Who cares?:
@ Yvonne I did not say you were a hypocrite. I try to avoid pointing fingers. I was speaking very generally and I'm sorry you interpreted otherwise. I have said time and time again that I understand that there are good reasons not to like a character, the thing I don't understand is why people in general have to be so vocal about their disliking. Again I have never intentionally insulted you. I don't know if you intentionally insult me (please let me know if you do or don't) but I try to keep users out of discussion when debating characters. Never. I don't like making people feel bad, I really don't. And I'm sorry if you did feel insulted. Apologizing is all I can really do, if you don't care then there's really not much else I can say.

And just to be clear (because this was a problem on another pick) the italics are intended for emphasis not attitude or sass.

@minervadawn Thank you for this advise. I think we all could use someone to help figure things out, because we get nowhere when we try alone.
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
claudia_bb picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
It's ok, @Princess.. I know what you mean.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
XxXrachellXxX picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
I'm upset they cut it, but if they're gonna bring it up again later, then I don't mind.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Who cares?
MariLena16 picked Who cares?:
It's a deleted scene from the episode or no? Because if it is a deleted scene & it is in YouTube there's no need to bring it again. It would be pointless to repeat it again.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
Fieryrubes picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
Would've been interesting.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
What!? They cut it!? Why would...
LowriLorenza89 picked What!? They cut it!? Why would they do that!?:
Since Graham's murder was never brought up in the series, I interpret the deletion of this scene as the writers deciding that it was just easier to ignore it all.
posted un mese fa.