Brooke is defiantly the better crier. I don't think I have ever seen Nathan cry Lucas is the worst crier on the show.

He cries less often so it's more important when he does it! :P

i'm more of a brooke fan but that crying scene wen peyton finds that ellie died in season 3 and she drops all the cd's etc....that was so heart-breaking

"why wont you let me all the way in" omg i cried soo much when brooke said that!!!

no nathan did cry, remember when he got in trouble for "point shaving"? it was sooo sad he almost had peyton & brooke crying w// him. i think peyton, brooke & nathan cry so heartbreakingly ='(

I agree with coldplaycrazy, Peyton made me cry during that scene. She is an amazing actress!

yeah chlarkfan...dat was real heartbreakin.....loved peyton cry aswell......i defo agree with d comments

yah .. the peyton was sooo sad.. also when lucas tells his mom about his HCM :(

I think that one of the reasons brooke was so good at crying at the end of season 3 because chad cheated on her in real life and she needed to get it out! also in season one she was an AWESOME crier and in EVREY season =)

she is amazing actress

Sophia is an amazing actress and i did love that scene that Chlarkfan pointed out but when poor Peyton found Ellie dead that was heartbreaking!

Peyton there is no doubt about that. Ellie's death, when she thought her father died in the storm, pregnancy issues and so many more.