he was a sweetheart. i miss the old luke. but not the aspects of him that have carried onto s5. he still hasn't grown past his habit of hiding with women so he doesn't have to confront/admit his feelings. sorry, back to the question. He was more of a butt in s5, heh. he was a sweet guy in s1 who screwed up BIG time. that's all.

*He was a jerk, but at least he changed his attitude in the end of that season. He was cheating on Brooke after she told him how much he ment to her. I`m glad he realized what he has done and decided to go somewhere with Keith.

i dont think that he was an ass in s1!!he was a child that tried to do the right things in his opinion and who couldnt hide his feelings but screwed things up!!he was young and sweet!!s5 Luke though is an ass coz his not young he is not sweet he a grown man who cant face his feelings making others around him hurt!!

at first he was but after that he was really sweet and all that.

he wasnt exactly an ass but what he did to brooke was wrong but when i look back the only person who didnt piss me off at some point in season one was haley

he was a loser with what he did to brooke but i loved him! :) that was the good old days when he followed his heart and knew what he wanted! apart from when he hurt brooke he was sweet! he made one mistake and it didnt make him a bad person, after he did it he regreted (round about s2 he did anyway lol) he was a high school kid, what you expect!

s5 he should know better!! he knows peyton loves him, he didnt know that brooke loved him s1! hes just a dickhead s5 hate him now!

But not only becaus e of what he did to Brooke. He was an ass all around that season. He slept with Nicki! I mean damn boy and he was a jerk to Keith and to Haley...he was a mess I really didn't like him that much at all.

^^ he was a mess? he still is lol!

sort of but hes worse in season 5!

He was only an ass to brooke- he was really sweet other then that. But what peyton and he did couldn't be forgiven despite the fact they were good people besides that one mistake: but it was a HUGE mistake and that is why i HATED them in s1. (especially peyton). But, I forgave them in s2- unlike some insane haley bashers that still hold that lame "went on tour" grudge.- Nathan forgave her. Why can't you?

^^ err i hate her for other reasons too - not just the whole chris keller thing - i was shocked by that but thats not why i hate her!

and Nathan forgave her. Why can't you? - that question applys to most brucasers - brooke forgave peyton, why cant you? ... they can forgive luke in a click of a finger but they cant forgive peyton!

right i hate haley cause shes a stuck up cow thinking shes better than everyone else ... you keep saying i should like her cause of what shes done for peyton ... shes only been there for peyton the last couple of episodes!! were was she the beginning of s5 when she was bumin off manface? ... halye thinks shes such a good friend ... shes anything BUT!!

first she tells peyton to get over luke - peyt tries to let luke go and shes convinced he doesnt love her - then haley comes along all pro leyton telling her luke does love her - tell me how that helps peyton? all it did was make her confused and hurt when luke said he hated her! dont get me wrong i love paley and how halet is there for peyton NOW ... but the last time she was really there for her was s1! - all halet is been since then is judgemntal of leyton and how they keep kissing! but shes doesnt take it out on luke - no she could never do that to luke, she takes it out on peyton!! having a go at her when luke is just as much at fault as peyton, actually no, lukes more at fault - peytons not dating anyone, luke was the one in the relationship- i mean you would of thought he would of learnt by now!
aswell when halet blamed peyton for leyton being over saying she shouldnt of said no!! ... luke was the one that walked away and peyton said SOMEDAYY!! ... halet didnt wanna listen to peytons side of the story cause peytons side isnt good enough for HJS!! << shes only got on sided view when it comes to other people like they should always choose right from wrong! but when it comes to herself she can do what she wants (like the CK - thats an example not a reason - the point that im trying to show is she can say one thing and do something else, shes a hypocrite)
i mean she also judged nathan, not just peyton! like when nathan did the point shaving, she nearly left him, or when he hits out at people!- halets hurt nathan quite a bit, in s5 she didnt wanna hear his side of the story just like she didnt wanna hear peytons!

^^ there some of the reasons i dont like her ... not just the CK thing!! i cant believe you think were like that you know, just hating her cause of chris that happened like 3 seasons ago- ive let go of that by now, leyton fans cant judge her for the CK, cause leyton have done it 3 times now! i have many other reasons why i hate halet but i cba writing more! ... and i know a few brucas fans who hate haley too, so its not just leytoners for whats shes done to peyton!!

but after that he went DOWN DOWN DOWN!

On the cheating, yes. He really is an ass. To think that I liked him more than Nathan in that season!

there is nothing better than luke in season one...my favorite season for luke...and still my favorite season of oth...sure he didn't handle the brooke situation very well...but well we all make our mistakes...

toally agree Nem!

He's always had ass qualities :P