rispondi a questa domanda

Severus Snape & Lily Evans Domanda

What was your opinion on Sev before te read 'The Prince's Tale?' How has it changed?

*
da the way, here's my answer: Before 'The Prince's Tale, I enjoyed Leggere about Sev, but never thought about him much. However I always though he must have an intresting background story - and I was right! Now he is one of my fav. characters (along with Lily)
SilverDoe29 posted più di un anno fa
*
I think a samll part of everybody always loved Snape. there were just people that denied it da saying he was cruel and evil. I've had that happen in so many books.
Spottedpool posted più di un anno fa
*
*small
Spottedpool posted più di un anno fa
 SilverDoe29 posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Severus Snape & Lily Evans Risposte

MadamOcta13 said:
I always thought that Snape was a dark person inside and out. I thought he was cruel and unfair and I wasn't surprised when I found out he was (at that time I would've used the word "is") a Death Eater. After I read "The Prince's Tale", my opinion changed completely. I viewed him as a misunderstood boy growing up. I was surprised to find that he was bullied instead of being a bully. He ended up on the wrong path, and once he Lost the Amore of his life, he Lost everything real in his life. From that point on, he tried to make things right da working for Dumbledore and trying to protect Harry (although he disliked him because of his father).
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Exactly what i thought!!
Sarah715 posted più di un anno fa
*
Well said. But I always liked Snape before knowing about The Prince's Tale.
MrsEmmaPeel posted più di un anno fa
bri-marie said:
I adored Severus before The Prince's Tale. He was my preferito character.

I never thought he was the bad guy, that there was più to him than being the 'greasy git of a teacher.' I respected him and loved him. When I read The Prince's Tale I understood him, felt sorry for him, and loved him even more.

I was also delighted that I could now tell everyone who had told me I was crazy for thinking he wasn't a bad guy and *SPOILER!!* loved Lily, "I told te so!" exuberantly.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I was exactly like te ! I'm so glad I was right ^^
allisparis posted più di un anno fa
*
I was the same as you!!
MrsEmmaPeel posted più di un anno fa
spockrocks said:
To be honest, I absolutely hated him. I thought he was cruel and at times unfair. I especially hated him after he killed Dumbledore. After seeing Deathly Hallows part 2 for a secondo time, I finally realised he was doing everything out of his Amore for Lily. (Didn't pay much attention during the book o the movie the first time)
select as best answer
 To be honest, I absolutely hated him. I thought he was cruel and at times unfair. I especially hated him after he killed Dumbledore. After seeing Deathly Hallows part 2 for a secondo time, I finally realised he was doing everything out of his Amore for Lily. (Didn't pay much attention during the book o the movie the first time)
posted più di un anno fa 
pancakeschocho said:
I never relay liked Snape. He was this cruel teacher who gave out unfair punishments. After I found out about his past, not much changed. He was horrible to all students not Slytherin, like when Hermione would know the answer. He also became Neville's WORST fear because he bullied him so much. That's saying something. I know, his past was riddled with horrible things, but in the end, he wasn't a hero. JK detto somewhere that she didn't want Snape to be treated as a hero, o that he was suddenly redeemed for all that he did. She just wanted to mostra più depth to him and mostra his good qualities. In the end, Snape was still not this huge hero everyone seems to want to play him out as in my eyes.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »