rispondi a questa domanda

Severus Piton Domanda

I cannot belive he is a Death eater can you??

Well, he is mean so I'm not shocked but A death eater he is lying to dumbledore
*
Thanks I will finish half blood price cause i'm Leggere it!
bananaboo posted più di un anno fa
 bananaboo posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Severus Piton  migliore risposta

Aquilia said:
Reply to NataliaLidia
Severus Snape may be evil, but then his Amore for Lily made him do several things inconsistent with what an evil person would do. He feels terrible grief and remorse for causing her death and even agrees to spy and act as an double-agent on Lord Voldemort for Dumbledore because of his grief. Now, if he was outright evil. He would have taken immense pride in helping his master remove a serious threat, no matter the collateral damage. He didn't, if Snape was ruthlessly evil, he would have not cared at all if the Amore of his life died as a consequence of his plots o not. He did care, why? Why if he is so evil as NataliaLidia claims? I answer myself: He might not be as evil as she portrays him, despite the affiliations and alliegences he had.
Let me quote Chaucer: amor vincit omnia - Amore conquers all.
So in the context of love, Snape's actions seem entirely plausible, he hates Harry because Harry is a mirror image of the person that ha rubato, stola the Amore of his life. He agrees to help Dumbledore and the Order of the Phoenix because he wishes to repay Lily for taking her life. He walks on burning coal because he has this thing called Amore and remorse. Now please do name one single outright evil person that really really regrets his actions. While te do that, I conclude:
Snape is not an evil person as he really wants to mend the disaster he has caused to his own life. Comparing to another HP character: Bellatrix Lestrange, she haven't got the single thought of remorse yet. Instead, Mdme. Lestrange enjoyed the insanity she caused Mr. and Mrs. Longbottom to the point where she might be deemed insane herself. If Snape felt the same, we would have seen him enjoy the deaths he caused Mr. Potter, Snape never mentioned James in a positive light in the books, because of hate. But in the seventh book we see him ask Dumbledore to hide James as well when confronted head on with the question. A evil person would have not cared for his rival that much, so again I - We must conclude that Snape does not qualify to be evil. Quod Erat Demonstrandum.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Very nicely put :)
bri-marie posted più di un anno fa
*
very nicely written. voted best answer.
lilith84 posted più di un anno fa
*
I am so very glad I wasn't here when this thread originally started. Absolute Best Answer.
BlackHound posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Risposte

bri-marie said:
Actually . . . I can. After seeing everything that he went through as a child and while in Hogwarts, I can completely believe that he joined a group of very powerful group of people who seemed to accept him.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I think the operative wrd in this domanda is "IS" and we know he really isn't, even if technically he is. <---did that make sense?
lilith84 posted più di un anno fa
*
Haha, yeah. But, see, he was a Death Eater, a true Death Eater, at one point in time. He never really left, even if he technically did. Wow, that was confusing XD
bri-marie posted più di un anno fa
*
Yep.
bri-marie posted più di un anno fa
lilith84 said:
I suggest Leggere the last book if te still haven't.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Why do te always take the words right out of my mouth?
LoveforSeverus posted più di un anno fa
*
looks like you're ready to unisciti me and LadyLilith in the 'sharing brain' thingy :P
lilith84 posted più di un anno fa
*
Welcome to the family! And yay, I feel loved JavaJoker. :3
LadyLilith posted più di un anno fa
ozlynknightmoon said:
yes i can belive snape is a death eater but i cant belive he is dead.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Well.. in the libri he may be 'dead' but... he isn't! ;) :D
SnapesRose posted più di un anno fa
SnapesRose said:
I think for me, when I found out that he was a Death Eater... it just added to his attraction... :D Purrrrr... but then from the 2nd book on I knew he was on the good side, I just knew! ;)
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
thank te he has to live for all of us
ozlynknightmoon posted più di un anno fa
NataliaLidia said:
yes cos his evil!!!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Did te even read the last book?
bri-marie posted più di un anno fa
*
NATALIA te haven't read the last book have you? cuz if so, then you'll know that Dumbledore him self has planning to get rid all muggles with his old friend Grindelwald, but he as so severus changed his mind cuz they're growing up
rainmad posted più di un anno fa
*
snape dint change dumbledoress ming!!! he wast even a live then!!! wat are te talkin about???
NataliaLidia posted più di un anno fa
pensatibo said:
read the 7th book.in their tells u about snape's life.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
LadyLilith said:
Aquilia and bri-marie detto it all for me, but I wanted to answer anyway. *Shrug* I can believe he's a Death Eater.

te guys all rock, da the way. :D Not as much as Severus o Alan (no one can be up there), but te rock very hard all the same. I Amore my perverted Snape/Alan family!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
It's good to know I am not alone with my perverted thoughts ;)
bri-marie posted più di un anno fa
*
we Amore ya too LL! :)
lilith84 posted più di un anno fa
*
and I Amore y'all guys.
rainmad posted più di un anno fa
rainmad said:
yeah, I think severus hates his "muggle" father, and thus hates all muggles, so he was very much wanted to be a death eater at first
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
well, it's not about "belive o not believe" but più about "can o can not"- te understand him.
rainmad posted più di un anno fa
*
tat dosnt even make sense!!! voldy wasnt jus a bout killing muggles!!! it was blood trators nd mudbloods too!!!
NataliaLidia posted più di un anno fa
*
Snape loved Lily - and she was a 'mudblood'. He was just trying to impress her da becoming a death eater, but that just worsened their relationship. Secondly - he was a teenager when he became one; he was in Slytherin and he was hanging with the wrong people. There was many, many più reasons why, but that is just a few of them.
jbduenweg07 posted più di un anno fa
avadakedavra said:
i cannot deny that eventhough dumbledore trusted him so much, i doubted his faithfulness. i cannot say that i didn't expected that he is still a death eater because somehow, like what i've said, i doubted him. when he killed dumbledore in book 6(in which he used my username "avada kedavra" lol) i hated him sooo much. it's like, how could he do that?! dumbledore, though powerful and wise, was old and getting weaker and weaker. i actually cried that time. :'(
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »