Is Atsuya better than Shirou?

well, who knows? maybe equal to shirou.

I Amore them both equally! Fubuki has a kind and gentle cuore and is a wonderful defender! Atsuya is energetic and is friendly! Both are cute and have a feeling of Amore for everyone. It's really sad that Atsuya had to die... But Fubuki and atsuya merged together make them an absolute great lenkai! Plus it made them( the merged Fubuki and Atsuya) absolutely cute!!

don't know but NO

atsuya it kind of cute and looks like shorou but sherou is better than him so that y i Amore him i get shyer than before =0.0=

i don't think so atsuya is cute but he is so rude and shiro is cute kind awesome player that's y shiro is better

No, Atsuya isn´t better than Shirou.
At first they were equal cuz Shirou was a good defender but not a good inoltrare, avanti while Atsuya was a good inoltrare, avanti but not a good defender.
Now Shirou´s better cuz he has become a good defender and inoltrare, avanti while Atsuya couldn´t become stronger.
But I think if Atsuya would still be alive they still would be equal cuz both had become stronger.

OMG OMG I CAN'T CHOOSSEE!! (mela-dramatic moment, sorry!) they are both amazing Buuuuuuuuuuuuuutttttttt........Fubuki, end of subject!
....sorry Atsuya...:'( your as amazing as your lil bro but he is cuter!