rispondi a questa domanda

Twilight la saga Domanda

who thinks that the twilight movie was as good as the book? who thinks it was good?!

 jasperforever posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Twilight la saga Risposte

sinai114 said:
Hi, personally this is my opinion. First of all I can agree like alot of twilight fan that the movie was not exactly what we can understand to be perfection.We all have imaginations and therefore we imagined the characters to be più beautiful, o to have certain traits to be as pronounced as we imagined them. I remember when the cast was selected, there was alot of commotion about whether o not they were going to be good for the part o not, alot of people were against Rober Pattinson being Edward, and specially Kristen Stewart being Bella. But in my point of view, I believe that the movie did do the book justice. It is extremely hard for any person in the world to try to interpret words into images, and let alone compress a very long and detailed book into a couple of hours o what not. I think the movie was great, we couldn't expect to see the whole "love" transformation that took place between Bella and Edward because of the time limit, also the producers didn't exactly know how to handle the fact that they weren't completely sure what the fan were going to like and what they weren't going to lack until the movie came out. There were parts that weren't in the book, but I think they were fantastic! For example, the whole "This stuff just doesn't exist, it does in my world" Climbing in the trees, scene was beautiful,along with the whole Pianoforte escenario. New Moon will not be accepted da me to have a lack of doing the book justice, because now everybody knows what fan didn't originally like from the first movie, and therefore they have a chance to improve themselves da alot, as well as the actors, based on their recitazione skills. Besides, we all know a book is always better than a movie.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I totally agree with most of the things that te postato (still think the movie's better) :)
sapherequeen posted più di un anno fa
*
I AGREE THE MOVIE WAS GOOD BUT THE BOOK WAS BEYOND GREAT
Bellas_twin posted più di un anno fa
*
Great answer :)
JoseVanders posted più di un anno fa
nataliespn said:
Well I first saw the movie and then read the book.I think that the book was much better but the movie was awesome too my favourite movie since then!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
BellaCullen8318 said:
No it was not as good as the book, haha but u know my opinion Paige!! haha
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Hellohoudini said:
Amore the books....Love the movie! Can't wait for New Moon!!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
myfrau said:
think that the book is better coz it contains a lot of details which aren't in the movie, though the film is also good(one of my favs)[:
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
tiiare said:
ok, in my opinion i think the movie was preety god, because it doesnt have to be exactly how its written in th book, u know? and it will be really hard 2 find someone beautiful as edward! i think the cast did a great job, and i really really like the movie, and the libri too!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Teengirl018 said:
Obiously! If it isn't then why would it be so POPULAR?
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
booksmad said:
I am Twilight obsessed i Amore the book and i think the movie is fantastic and does the book justice. But i do prefer Leggere the book as some of my fav. sences from it wern't in the movie
CAN'T wait for New Moon to come out
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
summerfrog said:
NO!! the movie messed it all up! and added things that aren't suppose to be there and took away things that were important and it was so bad against the book but, not comparing it to the book its a good movie and i Amore it (not nearly as much as the book though)
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
mayra7632000 said:
i don't think that the movie was near as good as the book..i was kind of disappointed...i thought that the movie was going to be hand in hand with the book..but it wasn't in my opinion...hopefully new moon will do better

=D
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Brysis said:
NO WAY... i mean i loved the movie and i´ve saw it God knows how many times but Twilight book is soooooooooooooo much better!! libri are ALWAYS better than the movies!!
We can see that da Harry Potter!! and now da Twilight

...Lord of Rings and i could continue!!! i guess i made my point!!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
sapherequeen said:
There may have been some significant scenes cut out, but I personally think the movie was better the the book! I mean, the movie was action-filled and even had some scary parts (I Amore HORROR Film :D) and it was actually a little fascinating with seeing the Cullens play baseball and Edward saving Bella from being crushed da Tyler's truck for yourself instead of Leggere it in a book :)
Well, that's my opinion but it's a strong one :D
select as best answer
 There may have been some significant scenes cut out, but I personally think the movie was better the the book! I mean, the movie was action-filled and even had some scary parts (I Amore HORROR Film :D) and it was actually a little fascinating with seeing the Cullens play baseball and Edward saving Bella from being crushed da Tyler's truck for yourself instead of Leggere it in a book :) Well, that's my opinion but it's a strong one :D
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I know what te mean but i don´t agree with te maybe it´s because i read Twilight first and then i saw the movie (don´t know if it´s the same with you) but the libri are so much better and somehow i know it will saty this way
Brysis posted più di un anno fa
*
But seeing the Cullens playing baseball (and in this i have to agree) is SSSSSOOOOOOOOOOOO much better than the book... ist my fav part EVER
Brysis posted più di un anno fa
finchesx said:
I liked the twilight movie, but the libri are WAY better than the movie. They're like much più detailed than the movie.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
paz-janae said:
it was not as good as the book but i liked it
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Bellas_twin said:
The book was better coz it had più detail into Bella's life and its più interesting I Amore IT!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
1hotvamp said:
It was different
The book was great with all the little details
But the movie was amazing
I cant wait for the new moon
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »