rispondi a questa domanda

Twilight la saga Domanda

Did New Moon change your opinion on Edward?

It did for me. I was thinking, almost everyone would be team Edward if he didn't leave in New Moon because that was like the only bad thing he ever did. When te read New Moon, did his actions change your opinion on him from Twilight??
 Edward_Bella234 posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Twilight la saga Risposte

mandapanda said:
To be honest, not really. I mean, even if we didnt know he left her to save her, he was still my preferito character. I actually got through the book faster, trying to see when he comes back. haha I knew he would. We don't know how much it hurt him until chapter 22 of eclipse, but we catch glimpese of it until then. so no, my opinion of him did not change. And I wouldn't necesarily say that when he left her was a bad decision. He went with the one he thought was right for her. He didn't know how much it would hurt each of them to be apart. He thought she would get over him. He didn't think that even if he detto she could sposta on, that she would still cling to him. So, it can be interpretted different ways i guess. Now, Jacob, my opinion changed of him alot! but I'll save that for another time. haha

But his cuore did break, not literally, but mentally, he Lost the will to live. He was just a being stuck in this lifeless world. Like Edward said, "Before te Bella, my life was like a moonless night. Very dark, but there were stars- points of light and reason. And then te shott across my sky like a meteor. Suddenly everthing was on fire. There was brilliancy, there was beauty. When te were gone, when the meteor had fallen over the horizon, everything went black. Nothing had changed, but my eyes were blinded da the light. I couldn't see the stars anymore. And there was no più reason for anything." He didn't have the will, the strength to live, but he was stuck in this lifeless, forgive the pun, world. She was his life, and when she was gone, when he hurt her to save her, he didn't have anything to live for.

very good domanda da the way :D
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Well...I couldn't agree more:)
tototo19 posted più di un anno fa
*
aw thanks :D
mandapanda posted più di un anno fa
*
Well said!
sarabeara posted più di un anno fa
tototo19 said:
I don't know...I always liked him, his character...Dunno, but he'll always be Edward for me, with o without the Amore triangle. I know he left some pretty serious damage, and Jake was the one who fixed Bella (not entirely, but he did), but Edward did what he thought was ok, and the only thing that changed was that he loved Bella even more, so I wouldn't say anything about him changed from my point of view...he's just...Edward...he stayed true to himself, and quite honest, I even liked him più when he explained Bella how much she means to him...
So I think of him now better than in Twilight...
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Twilghtsagafan1 said:
I didnt think so. He left to save her... and thats a very cool thing he did. It broke her cuore though. I was sad. I knew he would come back though. He's still my preferito character of all time in the saga!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »