do u think edward did the right thing in New Moon da leaving Bella? if not what r ur fellings toward him?

i would NEVER hate Edward, and he leave bella cause he wanted to protect her..he didn't want to hurt her that was much più harder for edward to leave bella so no and i'm team edward

i think Edward did the right thing da taking the decision of leaving Bella in NEW MOON , beacause he always wanted to make Bella safe.So from his perspective it was quite a right decision.But he did not consider the other problems e.g. Victoria,but he did not know about that at all.So Edward may be right from his perspective but as a reader who is equally sympathetic to Bella i should say Edward should have heard about bella's feelings too.So the conclusion is the situations controlled their lives and decisions.I am equally touched da both their feelings...as a sensitive and caring lover EDWARD did the right thing and i appreciate it.

i think that was a little stupid, because, he knows he Amore her, and he knows he can't live without her. but, thank God afer all they are together forever.

I think he did the right choice from his pow. Because he thought this was best for Bella and he always wanted just the best for her. If te sit to think about it it is one hell of a sacrifice the one he made also. Because he loved her più than ANYTHING and it was so damn hard for him to leave her. In fact this shows just zappa much he cared about her. He was willing to sentence himself to an eternity of misery without her just for her to be alive and happy even if with somebody else. Of course from Bella's pow he didn't do the right thing but she thought that he left her because he didn't loved her any more. When she found out the true reason of course she forgave him. Although he wasn't quite able to forgive himself for doing that :) wow I hope my long answer doesn't bother anyone lol

I dont think edward is right. He should have known what will happen to bella after he leaves. I agree with alice, 'he is a fool to think that te could survive alone'

No i dont hate edward at all he left bella cause he want her to be safe. Edward is the best i Amore him .

I didn't like his actions, but I think it was the best thing for Bella, so she can't be hurt again.

I am not mad at him for it because, even though I dont think he did the right thing,I believe that he did what he believed was right at the time. Like Alice detto in Eclipse, Edward has a tendancy to overreact. Clearly though, he had no intention of hurting Bella. He only wanted to keep her safe, and to maybe give her a chance at a normal life. He hated himself for hurting her.