rispondi a questa domanda

Harry Potter vs Twilight Domanda

Is Bella cigno Ribelle - The Brave o a coward?

Explain your answer. I see a lot of people say "Bella's not brave" in all the domande where te have to sort her into a hogwarts house, but nobody ever explains. They just leave it at "she's not brave". This is your chance to explain.



I can't think of a moment where she was a coward. She has basic human fears of things that are going to kill her, but so do Harry, Ron, and Hermione. How is she più cowardly than them, if te think she is?
 goodtimes posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight Risposte

graystone said:
Well, I know Stephanie really tried to make Bella look 'brave' in her books. If te have read Midnight Sun you'll come to know of how Edward describes Bella as being 'brave' for not letting others take of her(when she faints after blood typing). But then again are most people. That not extra-ordinarily Ribelle - The Brave o anything like what Meyer claims Bella to be.
Meyer also makes Bella look 'brave' for moving to the cloudy, gloomy Forks(although Renee insists that Bella needn't).
successivo thing is how 'brave' Bella is for being with her vampire boyfriend and not being scared. I know Stephanie intended to make Bella look braver than all of humanity. But it merely points out that, she doesn't even have the wits of figure out the sensible choice.
And about Bella going to the ballet studio to save her mother, okay, can't argue with that. But of course, it could have been done better. She was with 7 super-strong vampires. Obviously they could have done much più to save Renee than she could possibly have done. Yet, there again Meyer wants Bella to look idiotically 'brave'.
And don't even get me started on how 'brave' Bella is for jumping off cliffs and getting herself almost killed da motorbike accidents. That's stupid and'reckless'.

Bottom line:Bella is idiotically 'brave'/stupid.

select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Very well detto
FleetingFancy posted più di un anno fa
*
I didn't turn anything around. te detto Hermione thought she had to erase her parents' memory, and I detto the same thing.
youknowit101 posted più di un anno fa
*
I thought the discussion was about whether Bella is a coward o not. It says nothing about Hermione.
graystone posted più di un anno fa
severussnape13 said:
Coward. I think this pic explains it all. when I saw it i started laughing so hard i forgot to breathe. I honestly think that this is what she really seems to do.:)

select as best answer
 Coward. I think this pic explains it all. when I saw it i started laughing so hard i forgot to breathe. I honestly think that this is what she really seems to do.:)
posted più di un anno fa 
*
te didn't explain anything, and in that picture she's laying down because she has a broken leg
goodtimes posted più di un anno fa
adultswimperson said:
Meh...
Hermione can do so much better and has a strong act to do dangerous things, I haven't seen Bella do shit.>_>
In the Twilight Film nobody has seen her risk her life for anything, so that means she is a coward to step up.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Did te even watch them? Did te not see Bella rush off to James to be killed in place of her mother?
cassie-1-2-3 posted più di un anno fa
*
Isn't that in the summary too, where she's talking about how she never thought about how she'd die, but in the place of someone else sounded good?
zanhar1 posted più di un anno fa
*
In fairness, Hermione is a lot stronger than Bella, and obviously più able to fight.
TheBreeze posted più di un anno fa
*
Bella doesn't have magic to do everything for her. Any fighting Bella would have to do would have to be with her hands. I don't know why people expect her to punch, punzone Vampiri#From Dracula to Buffy... and all creatures of the night in between. in battle. Hermione wouldn't be able to physically fight a vampire either.
youknowit101 posted più di un anno fa
zanhar1 said:
*Is on the fence with this one*
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
alisonfaith297 said:
can i just say that i dont think bella is not brave, she is Ribelle - The Brave da the very fine definition of brave. the problem i see mainly is that people compare it to HP. it not exactly fair. harry, ron and hermione were placed in a different situation. i would say bella is più selfish in a sense. i not saying she is not selfless, she definately is when it come to edwards but i find they way meyer portrayed bella makes her seem like she only cares about her Amore for edwards.. i mean its not the only thing but its the main thing. so in that sense, to me personally, she comes of a bit self centered, therefore in someways misinterpreted with brave. like i detto this is più a feeling i get from the libri when i read about bella, so dont go bashing this with fact of any sorts. i know about the facts like her enduring childbirth etc. but all she ever seems to do, is più for the sake of her o edward.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
KirbyDerby said:
She's not brave, but she's not COMPLETELY cowardly either. In fact, that's how everything about her is... She's purely average.
An example of when she acted cowardly: When Edward left her. Now that was just pathetic.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
How was the way the Bella acted when Edward left her an example of cowardice? I think it was just her being extremely emotional and reacting, not being a coward because she didn't try to stray away from facing those emotions.
VampiresRevenge posted più di un anno fa
KitKatLex said:
There's not enough scenes to prove that if she is either Ribelle - The Brave o coward.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
FleetingFancy said:
Neither..
Not a coward but I wouldn't called her Ribelle - The Brave either.
recitazione on impulse/selfish desire mostly.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Shes not selfish.
CuteBlossom123 posted più di un anno fa
*
Sure
FleetingFancy posted più di un anno fa
*
I agree with te @FleetingFancy
jennipop22 posted più di un anno fa
alexisn10 said:
COWARD! Strong girls don't jump off cliffs when their boyfriends leave them. They either stay in their rooms and watch Titanic (I'd watch Don't Be a Menace it's not romantic but it;ll make me laugh and feel better :D) and eat Cioccolato o flip their hair and say 'on to the successivo one'. Seeing that millions of boys were falling for Bella when she first arrived to Forks, I would have shrugged and detto 'pimpin aint easy' and went home. Strong girls also don't hide in tents snogging with shirtless men while everyone else fights for MY SAFETY!
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Sometimes a giorno o two of chocolate, Titanic, and moping with your Friends in sweatpants is what a girl needs! It doesn't make her weak just human :) That being said, Bella definitely took Post-Breakup Depression to the successivo level
kaatie posted più di un anno fa
*
Better movies*
ArcticWolf posted più di un anno fa
*
lol watching Titanic doesn't make te a coward (if so, then I'd be the biggest coward of all!). I detto that Bella should watch Titanic to make herself feel better as opposed to jumping off a cliff.
alexisn10 posted più di un anno fa
ClaireVoyant said:
I think I kind of agree with graystone^.
it's not that she is not Ribelle - The Brave o completely coward. she has her moment. but most of the time Smeyer exaggerate thing. as if trying to say
"oh bella capable of doing this Ribelle - The Brave small thing( that every people normaly would do and some peoples could handle it better) look at how Ribelle - The Brave she is when she suffering so much. nobody would do the same as her. she is so special"
which instead of making me symphatize with the character... I feel the same dreaded feeling when I read fanfiction with mary-sue as main character...

select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
mr-cullen said:
SHE IS brave....COZ she is only human between wolfs and vampires......she don't have any powers o skills like others.....
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Well Filch was a squib stuck in between good and evil wizards but te may nto necessarily call him brave. And he doesnt have powers o skills either.
ariba_c posted più di un anno fa
*
^So wht do u think Ribelle - The Brave really means........????????????
MISS_ATTITUDE2 posted più di un anno fa
*
I'm pretty sure his point is that Bella has no power o skills, yet still endures confrontations. Like walking through a battlefield without any armor.
cassie-1-2-3 posted più di un anno fa
*
Which makes her stupid, not Ribelle - The Brave
yukka posted più di un anno fa
traceyhp said:
'Attention-seeking teen' is all I could think of when it comes to Bella Swan. Even though she'd go out of her way to solve Supernatural and dangerous conflicts, one thing is certain- about 80% of the time, she needs to be saved da someone else when she was the initial heroic.

This is proven in every book but New Moon. This story of the series proves how capable she is of an moronic plea for attention. (I.E. The cliff-diving to interact with Edward again) But her bravery in trying to save her mother without any assistance from any of the Cullen clan shows that she has a very bold and daring side to her seemingly limited personality. This justifies that she is Ribelle - The Brave but comes off as an lovelorn, attention-seeker in my opinion.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
she's not..................in my opinion
mr-cullen posted più di un anno fa
*
^Based off of certain actions she's taken- (whereas which Hogwarts house she'll likely end up in, she would be Gryffindor and hilarity would ensue :P), she fits in as an Ribelle - The Brave underdog. Her actions in New Moon lead to the 'attention-seeking' label as it pertains to her need of seeing/hearing from Edward again at any cost.
traceyhp posted più di un anno fa
*
I agree :3
zanhar1 posted più di un anno fa
edwardsgurl2012 said:
she iz sooooooooooo brave!!! i mean she sacrife life for reneesme!! she nearly dyed for her!!!! dats soooooooo brave!!!!!!!! ikr?? then she Ribelle - The Brave in eclipse.... shes a gr8 role model~~~~!!! rite??
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
She didn't really sacrifice herself for the baby. She sacrificed her human years but she knew that Edward would turn her into a vampire after the delivery. Sacrificing is what Harry's parents did for Harry, Snape did for Harry, and Harry did for everyone (note: he thought that he was going to die not knowing that he was the final Horcrux and would survive)
alexisn10 posted più di un anno fa
*
Well said.:)
graystone posted più di un anno fa
*
Great role model. Because great role modelle jump of cliffs, recklessly ride motor cycles, and mope around for months after being dumped. I'm sorry, but in my opinion she isn't a good role model. I will say her sacrifice to the baby was Ribelle - The Brave though.
zanhar1 posted più di un anno fa
yukka said:
Hermione charges into battle. Bella does too, but only when she can become invincible and have an army of equally invincible Vampiri#From Dracula to Buffy... and all creatures of the night in between. behind her, which she protects with her utterly pathetic superpower. When Hermione's boyfriend leaves her in the middle of the woods, she cries for a while, clears her head, and then devotes her life to fighting against the all-powerful dark lord again, with più vengeance than before. When Bella's boyfriend, who, da the way, is an old pale dead guy, leaves her in the woods, she jumps off a cliff, not caring what her Friends o family thought at all. When Hermione's boyfriend comes back, she flies into a rage and refuses to talk to him for weeks. When Bella's boyfriend comes back, she literally cries with happiness, forgetting that he left her stranded in the middle of the woods at night. Alone. When Hermione is confronted with the enemy, she gives it her all, fighting almost to the point of death. When Bella is confronted with the enemy, a vicious newborn vampire named Bree Tanner, she whines and hides behind her invincible boyfriend, scared to be eaten, perhaps.
That is all.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »