What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry Potter vs Twilight Stronger love?

99 fans picked:
Snape's Amore for Lily
   89%
Edwards Amore for Bella
   11%
 Harrypotter148 posted più di un anno fa
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

32 comments

user photo
Harrypotter148 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
If You Read The 7th Book You Will unsderstand and ptt edwwars and bllas love = NOT STRONG 0% STRONG
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
VampyreFey picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Snape truly loved Lily. His love for her was undeniably strong and pure. That's why he lost her in the end... forbidden, pure love.
They were friends, who cared for one another and looked deep within eachother. The challenges Snape faced in loving Lily, proved the strength of his love. It was devastating when he lost her, considering the immensity of his love.

Edward's love is really not love, it's just lust. Bella never describes who Edward truly is, and in the small event she does, she's extremely vague. She goes on describing how beautiful Edward is and that he sparkles and that there is no one as gorgeous as Edward. From what I can see there is no real love in this relationship, just extremely obsessive lust.

Okay, sorry about that, but I had to say it.
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
Mongoose09 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
No contest. I agree with the 2 people above :)
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
MadamOcta13 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Not only is Edward's love for Bella cheesy, but they've only known each other for a few years. Snape, on the other hand, loved Lily since they were kids!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
zelo picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Well said MadamOcta13 and VampyreFey, well said!!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
ToyletGnome picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
MadamOcta13 - they'd only known each other a few WEEKS when they decided it was "true love". Severus' eternal, undying love for Lily is beautiful and tragic. I cried buckets when I read the prince's tale. Bella and Edward, not at all.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
LadyLilith picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
This pick has been placed on this spot severus times (heehee =D), I think we've rubbed it in people's faces enough that Severus pwns Edward.

Sorry, just sick of answering and commenting on the same pick versed in a slightly different way. :P Even though I love Severus to death, and I relish him always winning over Edward.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Harrypotter148 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
^^^ shya!!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
SnapeSoulmate picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
He's so devoted, and his love is so pure that he did things no other wizard would do.

Edward is... Yes. A stalker, and would probably do simple measures for his "love".

Also, Severus would probably beat Eddy up to a pulp to the extent where he's running away sneezing sparkles.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Mrs-Grint picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
People actually picked the other option?!

PEOPLE IF YOU PICK THE OTHER OPTION. PLEASE COMMENT.

I'm not even going to go into depth why I chose this, I've already reasoned it so many times that I just can't be asked. And other people have already done it for me.
Team Severus! <3
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Kirkir picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Obviouslyy! He sacrificed his lifee for her!

Bella & Edward.. I rly hate them together :/ It's just some stupid obsession!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
nati30 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Snape's love and devotion to for Lily is surprisingly what has probably made me the most emotional throughout the entire series. I mean, just reading some crazy HP fan rant about them makes my eyes watery. Snape loves Lily so much! OK, lets compare: When Edward thought Bella was dead and he thought it was his fault, he goes and tries to kill himself. When Snape finds out Lily is dead and he blames himself, he WANTS to kill himself, but instead, he spends every last minute of his life making sure Lily got justice, he risked his life by lying to Voldemort, who can read minds, to bring down the man that killed the love of his life. Lily never even shared his love for her, she married another man, she married tha man that used to bully and humiliate Snape almost everyday, yet Sanpe remained faithful to her. If Bella hadn't smelled so great, Edward probably would never even have been interested in her!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
knight_princess picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
I know I posted this before but being best friends someone you love is to be the key to a good long-lasting relationship these days. Romance comes second. Friendship, Happiness and Loyalty come first.

Snape and Lily were best friends. I really love how Harry Potter in th last few books gained so much more plotlines and backstory, because if it was just books about a boy who is avenging his parents death and attends a wizarding school and has crazy stuff happen to him, it wouldn't have gotten so famous.
Key to a good story: Backstory. Powerful, heart-wrenching back-stories....

I agree with all!! Well Done!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
teamedwardgirl picked Edwards Amore for Bella:
HOW CAN YOU PEOPLE TELL YOURSELVES THESE LIES EVERY DAY OF YOUR B0RING LIVES?!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!??!!?!?!!?!?!?!?!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
BaSbooSa picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
^ There's no need for this. Why don't you just tell us why do you think that Edward's love for Bella is stronger than Snape's love for Lily and that's it. We are just expressing our opinions here.
OK, I think Snape's love for Lily is way stronger than Edward's love for Bella because as MadamOcta13 said, Snape loved Lily since they were kids and when she died I think this love grew stronger. I mean, sometimes he treated Harry harshly because he hated his father but the only thing that made him still take care of him and help him (Harry) is because he is the son of the woman he loves, even if he's from the man he hates.
And sorry if my English is bad but it's not my mother tounge >> I think I've said this many times LOL! =P
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
sleazy_weasley picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Okay, Siriusly, TeamEdward; have you even read HP 7? Have you not realized the love Snape holds for Lily? If you haven't, then I can say without doubt you're a pretty shallow reader. If you haven't read HP 7 at all, then you really shouldn't compare. I, on the other hand (along with many others on the cool side of the world), have read Twilight through to Breaking Dawn, and have also read Harry Potter 1-7. The characters, which have been so explicitly built, have grown and changed over time, and the audience realizes that Snape truly was the bravest man we ever knew. He endangered his life to save Lily's son, the son who was the mirror version of the guy who made Snape's life miserable at school. He saved Harry, for Lily. The last thing Snape saw before he died was Lily's eyes. The last thing he WANTED to see before he died, were Lily's eyes. If that doesn't make you weep, you're, well, for want of a better word, quite a heartless wretch.
Perhaps I didn't explain it very well; but if you read the extract (as well as having background information on Snape), you'll know what we're saying.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
potterrox picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
@teamedwardgirl- you say we are lying and then fail to explain why. I am honestly curious about your perspective and have respect for your opinions even if i don't agree. if you want to justify your opinion please do, if not, please don't scream at us over the internet.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Confuzzle picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
teamedwardgirl, what is your definition of "love"? Do you think it's watching people in their sleep? Following people? Because we think differently. It's caring about someone so much that you don't care if they marry your enemy, and when they die you take care of their son, even if he looks like his father, who bullied you. How exactly does Edward show that for Bella? The ultimate sacrifice so that her murderer is avenged?

After Sirius dies, Snape goes to his house to look for a remembrance of Lily. His love doesn't falter or die, but he never forgets her.

Severus and Lily met when Severus saw her doing magic, and he knew she was a Witch. He loved her, even then, because he was one of himself, and as they grew up he cared even more. Soon Snape turns to Death Eater ways, and he calls Lily a "mudblood". He regrets it, but Lily turns away. Even when their friendship dies, he doesn't lose hope.

There, I've given the definition. Think on that. And people don't love another because they wear nice perfume. :D
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
XDRoseLuvsHP picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
teamedwardgirl: Is that honestly the best you can do to support your opinion? That's pretty sad.

Now, Snape gave up everything for Lily. He let her go with the man she loved, even though he and Snape hated each other, and he never complained. He still loved her. Edward couldn't even let Bella talk to the boy she might have been friends with because of jealousy. He doesn't care about her feelings. He just lusts her. Snape switched sides because of Voldemort killing Lily. That destroyed him. He has always protected Harry in honor of Lily. When he died, his dying wish was to look into Lily's caring eyes (Harry does have Lily's eyes). He gave up everything for her, including his own happiness. Now THAT is true love. <3
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Catbr picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
@teamedwardgirl: Do you have to be rude all the time?
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
ToyletGnome picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
teamedwardgirl, can you please explain your answer? If you think Edward's love for Bella is stronger, what is your reasoning? I just don't see how any love in Bella and Edward's relationship exists.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
LadyLilith picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
"HOW CAN YOU PEOPLE TELL YOURSELVES THESE LIES EVERY DAY OF YOUR B0RING LIVES?!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!??!!?!?!!?!?!?!!?!­&qu­ot;

You just proved the Twihard stereotype true once again. Congrats, you bloody idiot. :D
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Mrs-Grint picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
*snort*
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
mispulka picked Edwards Amore for Bella:
Well.. After reading Midnight Sun I understand how desperately in love Edward is. I don't say I fancy the story. Meyer just made her 'vampires' more lovable because of the 'permanent and deep and sooooo strong love'.
So, I believe Edward's love is (was) stronger.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
boolander25 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
S.S. + L.E. 4ever. R.I.P both
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
DivyaHarry picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
I think if Snape were gorgeous like EddyPants teamedwardgirl would have loved him. Since all the TwiTards are about looks and therefore narrow-minded, I guess it's okay for her to feel this way.

Harry Potter fans, I applaud each and every one of you who believe love goes beyond looks and remains true even when it is unrequited. I miss Severus Snape, one of the bravest men I ever knew. *crying my eyes out*.

RIP Snape.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
vskparaimer picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Cullen's love for Swan is nothing, really, it's like a little of affection, little bit of flirt, something that is to last a moment and fly away. And Snape loves and loved and will love Lily with all his heart, deeply, romantically, passionately, all the time. and i love him too.

the whole twilight thing isn't interesting at any point if think about for a while.

Severus .... *sigh* well at least now he's together with Lily, in heaven.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
joose32 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
From the moment he first laid eyes on her as a child till his dying breath Severus Snape loved Lily Evans.
Even though she married his "nemesis" after high school. Even after her death which he in part is to blame. He vowed to protect her son. Not Lily & James Potter's son. Just Lily's son. Even though her son, whose the spitting image of his father but has Lily's eyes, reminded him everyday of the very man who made his life at Hogwarts miserable. He protected him. In secret. Took no credit for it. Put his own life in mortal jeopardy and ultimately died. Not to be a hero but for the love of his life Lily Evans.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
dobbyssocks picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
The best part about the snape lily love is that snape never said "I love Lily Evens" but you still know he does because jkr is a wonderful writer. I cant count how many times eddy and bella had to state that they "loved" each other
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
souflizzle317 picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
I'm really late to this question but I'm going to comment anyway :) dobbyssocks is right, there's not a single part in the entire series when Snape says that he loves Lily, either to her or to anyone else. But through his memories in The Prince's Tale and his actions throughout the series we can tell that what he felt for Lily was a deep, pure love and the reason it comes off so strong to readers is because it was always an unrequited love, one of the hardest things in life. Snape had to suffer losing Lily to James Potter and then he had to see the living proof for six straight years that Lily hadn't chosen him - Harry Potter. There were moments in The Prince's Tale when I found myself wishing that Lily had fallen in love with Snape, just because it's so heartbreaking, even though Harry wouldn't exist if that had happened, and then there wouldn't have been a series at all. But the emotion you feel when reading about Snape's love for Lily makes it impossible not to appreciate how strong he really is.

Edward's "love" for Bella? Psh, that's what you call lust. It's bad enough to compare it to Harry and Ginny's love or Ron and Hermione's, but to try and compare it to Snape's for Lily? All the Twihards who voted for Edward's love for Bella on this question should be ashamed.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
HaleyDewit picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
The love between Severus and Lily is one of the strongest I've ever known.A love that is so strong he protected the son of the man who got the girl he loved,because it was also her son.

The thing(I simply refuse to call it love)between Bella and Edward is based on physical desire,nothing more.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
TeamSiriusBlack picked Snape's Amore for Lily:
Love is when the person is dead, but you continue to love them no matter what.
posted più di un anno fa.