rispondi a questa domanda

Black Butler - Il maggiordomo diabolico Domanda

What do te think,Ciel get raped da those noblemans who sacrificed him?

I think this, becose in the Anime someone sad to Ciel that he is unclean and then showed a memory when Ciel was naked and to hold down da those noblemans.I hope its not true :)
*
Oh.come on! Tell me your opinions :)
andimyon posted più di un anno fa
*
I think they leave it open for speculation for purpose. This is a totally canon mostra made for pervs :) (Me being one of them)
bluesoles posted più di un anno fa
*
i agree and i dnt think its Yaoi either but i guess tht could be a matter of opinion.
YukixKyon4evr posted più di un anno fa
 andimyon posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Black Butler - Il maggiordomo diabolico Risposte

PhantomhiveLuna said:
He wasn't raped, first of all, and the fact that they did that to him, I think it's realllyy sad, I cried when I saw that.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Chorisu said:
I do think he was. The noblemen of that era tend to be corrupt.
Not only that, but if te were to look at the creator of the series, Yana Toboso, she has some pretty dirty mangas. So I wouldn't be surprised if it was rape.

I think that scene in the Anime was left ambiguous so we can decide for ourselves what happened.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Cait19 said:
I think he wasn't raped, just molested. The Angel did point out that he was unclean, probably because he is his parents child. In the secondo season Claude mentions that Ciel is pure whereas Alois is not. The two nobles have similar lives and yet so different from each other. When Claude says Ciel is pure and the Angel says he is unclean, these Citazioni led me to believe that Ciel was only molested da the noblemen. Alois was definatly raped da his pedo 'father' and is not his soul and blood was corrupted da his 'father' and is not pure because of it, making Claude (after tasting Ciels blood) want più of Ciel since Ciel is pure. From what I have also heared is that Demons Amore pure virgin souls from time to time. That is my opinion.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
videogamergirl said:
Apparently in the manga it was detto that the cultist gave Ciel "extra love" during his captivity. That and when children are kidnapped and held captive, they are usually raped. It's a hard truth. So I do believe that he was sexually assaulted in some way shape o form. He may not have been full fledged raped pursay, but he could've been molested.
And in the manga, Ciel put a gun to Sebastian's head while Sebastian was leaning over to waking him up and Ciel detto "Don't touch me" and he was shaking like crazy. So the fact that he doesn't want anyone to touch him in any way also shows signs he was sexually abused.
So there for, with other evidence from the manga I have, I do in fact believe he was sexually abused.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Susinko said:
It's possible. He was held da a cult and many cults believe that sexual energy is an important component in some spells and rituals. While I hope they didn't sexually abuse little Ciel, it's very possible.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Phantomhive1 said:
In this picture from the Book of Circus, it clearly shows him being held down at the neck and at his lower back. I always had a feeling that he was, but it was never mentioned so I didn't think much of it.
select as best answer
 In this picture from the Book of Circus, it clearly shows him being held down at the neck and at his lower back. I always had a feeling that he was, but it was never mentioned so I didn't think much of it.
posted più di un anno fa 
emiliux123 said:
Something like that really happened but I'm not sure for rape.It says that Ciel was abused physically and sexually(got it from Black Butler - Il maggiordomo diabolico wiki)so he may got raped.
Now here have a pic(as te can see he is bruised and kinda naked)
select as best answer
 Something like that really happened but I'm not sure for rape.It says that Ciel was abused physically and sexually(got it from Black Butler - Il maggiordomo diabolico wiki)so he may got raped. Now here have a pic(as te can see he is bruised and kinda naked)
posted più di un anno fa 
*
They don't look like bites o hickies. più like 'i just got beaten da people' marks.
Cait19 posted più di un anno fa
*
No. Those are dirt marks.. usually used to mostra beatings. People need to stop bringing their sick fantasies onto a kid.
Tamlen posted più di un anno fa
*
più like ran away and got beat up and now i am making a contract with a demon and my soon to be demon butler who can kick but
kawaiibunny posted più di un anno fa
KatzyKins said:
If the manga detto he was, then I believe it, but I think his purity comes most from his strength, despite what those disgusting people did to him, he doesn't let him define him the way that Alois does. Alois has become a very sexual child, and he uses it as a weapon of sorts. Ciel's sanity is stronger, Alois is constantly mostrare signs of being shaken and conflicted da the abuse he suffered. :c I always felt absolutely terrible for Alois because of it<3
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Laila_25 said:
No,not saying it's the truth but I think that Ciel didn't get raped,Ciel's been called unclean,I think that meant that Ciel's contracted with Sebastian...I think but in the guys holding Ciel down,naked meant that the noble man's branding Ciel...I'm not sure but I hope this will help you
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Ladymichaelis said:
I don't think he was raped, they just tried to sacrifice him. The reason he was naked in the memories that were shown was because they branded him, wich was part of the ritual, I think.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Tamlen said:
You're disgusting and te should feel bad.
That's what I think. This isn't yaoi.. that nasty stuff.
The r-word is the most unclean horrible thing,
and as someone who hasn't experienced it
please shut up. (ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ*:・゚✧
select as best answer
 You're disgusting and te should feel bad. That's what I think. This isn't yaoi.. that nasty stuff. The r-word is the most unclean horrible thing, and as someone who hasn't experienced it please shut up. (ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ*:・゚✧
posted più di un anno fa 
Lokinne said:
Taking the manga as main fonte I would say yes, probably he was raped da the noblemen. I mean, the whole situation doesn't seems to be only a black market of children for sacrifices, and Ciel was the child of the Phantomhive family, who someone wanted to see erased... It's a dark theme and matter, let's see if Yana clarifies something even with hints...
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
OneHellOfATime said:
No. Ciel was used as means of sacrifice for a cult ritual. He was branded and taken as a slave. That's why when he was naked and on the tavolo he was stabbed, not raped. That is also why he was referred to a "lamb" The higher the social standing, the più valuable te are.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Ciel was then sold, and his kidnappers commentato that he is "rare" and worth più than two people. He was bought and branded da his new owners, giving him the mark of a "noble beast." He cried that he was hurt, dirty, and homesick. He was then chained in a cage while masked adults looked on and remarked about what a splendid evening they will have. Ciel sadly wondered why no one was there to help him. One of the masked adults then placed him on a tavolo as a sacrifice, and he was stabbed while the rest looked on gleefully
OneHellOfATime posted più di un anno fa
DarkLadyCiel said:
I never thought Ciel was raped, I thought he was tortured o experimented on, but I suppose... I don't think it meant unclean in the sexual purity way, but in the kind soul and 'we think everyone in the world is unclean' way, having a demon for a butler isn't earning te brownie points from God.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
popsicleAyyy said:
This is as cannone as it gets people!! look at season on episode twelve at sixteen minuti and thirty seconds, then puppet master says AND I QUOTE' ceil phantomhive the body your in. is unclean' and it shoots to ceil naked and chained up with hands all over him, it has very heavy implications but paring that with his sensitivity to touch and physical contact at all I think it's a most definite yes. he was raped sexually abused and MANY other forms of abuse when he was being held da the cult.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »