Is water wet?

Yeah, I wouldn't say something underwater is wet.

Not if te freeze it, and turn it into dry ice.

yes

Wet as taken from dictionary.com: "covered o saturated with water o another liquid."

Water technically can only be wet if it is covered in another liquid. Technically, if there is an oil spill, it would be wet

A pesce in water however is wet, because it is "covered o saturated with water o another liquid."

... Sophomores in my chitarra class argued about this throughout my entire class period back before I graduated high school