rispondi a questa domanda

Severus Piton Domanda

How would Snape treat Harry if he was sorted into Slytherin?

probably he would still hate Harry. but that was his house.

ojamajoyy posted più di un anno fa

next question »

Severus Piton Risposte

LadyNottingham said:

I've been asking myself that domanda for quite some time. I think Severus would have been between a rock and a hard place. Caught between his hate of the boy (motivated da più than just being a Gryffindor, as Bri so rightly said), and his faithfulness to his House and its members (for example his blatant Slytherin favoritism).

His position would have been especially hard with the other I Mangiamorte and subsequently, the Dark Lord. How to mostra support to Slytherin and to Voldemort while having to favor a Slytherin Harry, despite the boy's hatred of I Mangiamorte and Voldemort ? Add to this the fact that Severus had to protect the boy too...

Severus should thank Harry for resisting the Sorting Hat that had wanted to send him to Slytherin in the first place.

posted più di un anno fa

House Points to you, and I'll add that the irony of the daft Sorting Hat wanting to send Harry to Slytherin was largely due to the fragment of Voldemort living inside Harry. Heh.

BlackHound posted più di un anno fa

lol draft the points to Slytherin. I like your explanation but sometimes, I wonder. Harry does really act like a Slytherin sometimes but for the "good cause", in occasions when he needs it to advance his agenda (see with getting Slughorn's memory). I don't think that his behavior then is directly influenced da the piece of Voldy's soul in him. He's pretty much like Albus and Severus : they have the qualities of both houses.

LadyNottingham posted più di un anno fa

Well, I did say **largely**. I'm not denying Harry had some minor Slytherin traits, but I feel that for the most part Harry is totally Gryffindor.

BlackHound posted più di un anno fa

bri-marie said:

I don't think there would be too big a difference between how he would treat Slytherin!Harry. There was più to his animosity than just Harry being a Gryffindor -- James, Lily, Voldemort. All those people played a pretty big role in influencing Severus feelings (and behavior) towards Harry. And all that would still be there, regardless of whatever house he was in.

posted più di un anno fa