rispondi a questa domanda

Twilight la saga Domanda

Why are Jacob & Bella considered as "soul mates" if there was no Edward?

I can't find the fonte for this point right now, maybe it was Jacob pretentious idea. *shrugs*
If Bella was Jacob real love/soul mate wouldn't he have just imprinted on her?
I remember him saying Edward shouldn't exist in Eclipse. So if da any chance this is true then is really Twilight a Jacob/Bella story?(*cough*)

 Renesmee_XD posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Twilight la saga Risposte

mandapanda said:
In Eclipse, Bella did say that Jacob would be her soul mate if they were in the normal world.

However, that never made sense to me. Also, Bella loving Edward and Jacob at the same time made me even più confused.

Bella loves Edward. But she also loves Jacob just not as much as she loves Edward. Jacob thinks he loves Bella più than Edward, but really, he loves Bella and Edward's unborn child Renesmee. So what were Bella's feelings for Jacob? Jacob never loved Bella like he claimed. His Amore was for Renesmee.

So the major flaw in this situation is... Stephenie Meyer's writing. She still fails to explain this without people getting so confused. The precedente question: "What were Bella's feelings for Jacob?" This right here, since Jacob never actually loved Bella in that way, that pull was always for Renesmee, makes Bella seem ignorant and shallow.

Even if Bella detto she loved Jacob in a non-brotherly way, there was a better way to establish that "love." Not once in Eclipse did Bella ever hint to us, the readers, that she saw Jacob in a different way. What Bella thinks, we read. Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse, 2/3's of Breaking Dawn, yet in Eclipse, when she detto she was trying to keep her feelings hidden for Jacob, we should have read that. A little hint, o fallback saying that Jacob was più to a brother to her. But it never detto she loved him. Not until after he forced her to baciare her.

This is the confusion that Stephenie Meyer created. And your question... NO. Twilight is not Bella and Jacob's story. To be honest, that's somewhat of a ridiculous theory haha Twilight started off as Bella's story. But, when it evolved into Bella and Edward's story, but still being told through Bella's thoughts.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
You're back!!! lol
Hellohoudini posted più di un anno fa
*
Dogly Amore lmao are te trying to promote beastiality here XD Well I completely disagree so it's a moot point really haha
katiecain posted più di un anno fa
*
haha and this is where we will always disagree! But I still Amore te anyways :P
mandapanda posted più di un anno fa
TrueTwi_hard said:
They arn't considered soulmates. They loved eachother, but they weren't in love.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I am sure the baciare at the end of Eclipse proved how much they were "in love" & also all the pain Bella caused Edward during Breaking Dawn da basically loving Jacob AFTER there marriage. Ugh.
Renesmee_XD posted più di un anno fa
*
their*
Renesmee_XD posted più di un anno fa
*
Well...Jacob tricked Bella. He detto he would die. And yes, they loved eachother. But Bella loves Edward più
TrueTwi_hard posted più di un anno fa
*
bella TOYS with jacob one giorno she wants to baciare successivo time she doesnt she SHOULD MAKE UP HER MIND!.
_ms_lautner posted più di un anno fa
Hellohoudini said:
I think te might be confusing story lines....Jacob and Bella were never considered 'soulmates'....Bella loved Jacob but it was "brotherly" Amore than real love...Jacob did Amore Bella but as it turned out was "in" Amore with the part of Bella that would become Nessie.

If there had been no Edward...I dont think Bella and Jacob would have been anything più than friends...

♥Team♥Twilight♥
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Do te not think they would have fallen in Amore eventually? With no Edward to create Renesmee
Renesmee_XD posted più di un anno fa
*
Meh, I meant including* not according :/
Renesmee_XD posted più di un anno fa
*
Who knows. Like I said, da normal world I think she means one where Edward wouldn't exist. She doesn't address who would be her soulmate if they both were humans, so it's a matter of opinion :)
katiecain posted più di un anno fa
Jeffersonian said:
Yeah, I hate how Bella claimed they were soulmates. A soulmate is the deepest level of love, so obviously Jacob isn't her soulmate, he's just a good friend, I don't care what she claims, she's fickle, confused and highly unintelligent in matters of love.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
LOL! ikr! i agree bellas just a idiot who wishes.! but still jacobs SOO hot team jacob!
_ms_lautner posted più di un anno fa
next question »