Anime recommendations?

Clannad, Clannad: After Story, D.N.Angel, Black Butler, Rozen Maiden, Trinity Blood, Death Note, Godchild, XXXholic

DANGIT te ha rubato, stola black butler...

uhm, i would say durarara, because it's the only Anime i watch thats romance, but it's not Gothic as much as dark.

I'd go with either Black Butler o Soul Eater. Neither have really much "romance" per say, but there are a few "romantic" elements added every once and a while. But Black Butler has some hinted shounen-ai stuff, so if Yaoi and all that makes te uncomfortable I think it's best to stay out of that... Soul Eater has a Gothic feel to it, but it's a lot of comedy that lightens up the dark aura it gives off.

I've also heard Death Note is good if te haven't seen it yet. I haven't myself, but I want to.

Well I don't know anything about Gothic o Dark but I can help with romance ^^
Ouran Highschool Host Club (A MUST SEE!!!)
Fruits Basket (Soooo sweet!)
Vampire Knight (Kind of goth is guess...)
School Rumble (Super funny!!)
Elfen Lied (this one is dark...almost twisted)
Death Note (WICKED AWESOME!!)

i would say soul eater i have only watched a couple episodes and it is just plain awesome

Fullmetal Alchemist is one dark Anime mostra that comes to mind then durarara is one of those that must watch to understand how it is and/or dark in some cases like the god what do they call the check with out her hear. Not her name but people with out thier heads that are still alive there was a word that they call those people. this is going to bug the crap out of me tell i find out. But back to the queston, ramance one i would say bleach

well i dont watch a lot of those i only watch death note from that category but heres what i got:
*vampire knight-never seen it but i heard its great
*death note-AMAZING! your gonna Amore it! great
story too!
*elfin lied-really dark!
*soul eater

i dont have a lot of death note pics but heres a pic of L! my fav death note character! hope te will give these a try

kuroshitsuji/black butler death note vampire knight shakugan no shana code geass elfen lied pandora hearts and più but i can't think of them right now : p

Good anime, but not exactly Gothic anime:
Iria: Zeiram the Animation, Twelve Kingdoms, Rurouni Kenshin, Full Metal Panic, Trigun, Cowboy Bebop, Giant Robo, Kino's Journey, Gungrave, Now and Then Here and There

Something in the lines of what te are describing:
Hellsing, Vampire Hunter D, Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust, Blood: the Last Vampire, Blood+, Berserk, Gantz, Elfen Lied, Pet negozio of Horrors, Hell Girl, Serial Experiments Lain, Blue Gender, Requiem from the Darkness, Perfect Blue

Hope this helps. Peace.

romance: shuffle!
gothic: Black Butler - Il maggiordomo diabolico (black butler)
dark: hell girl

Hanasaku Iroha is in the romance genre