The gang tries to find out who P.J.'s mystery boyfriend is. Bobby and P.J. try to keep their relationship a secret. Brendan is busy trying to get his club ready for business, and Andy is happy to get a night off.
PJ gets her own column in the paper but the guys think that it may be because of her looks rather than her writing. Meanwhile, Brendan brings Kenny to a new, exciting club.
During the annual board game decathlon, Bobby criticizes PJ for being competitive. Meanwhile Stephanie uses the guys as research for an articolo she is writing.
Brendan agrees to let PJ make all his decisions for him while Stephanie uses Mike as a guinea pig for her book seminar. Meanwhile, Kenny starts a band and takes it a little too seriously.
Kenny becomes Friends with the Dalai Lama on Facebook, and the gang convinces Bobby to join. Bobby learns that PJ is Friends with all of her ex-boyfriends. Mike and Brandon compete for a woman with Mike using Facebook to help him.