I was as shocked as most of te da the ill conceived writings of Shaina Fewell, detto writer of the debauchery of 8x12. But I see it like this. We all at one time o another enjoyed Brooke and Peyton's friendship. But we all know Breyton is almost if not più a hot button ship than the rest, just because they were so on and off.
It's obvious who I like, but I can see why others see it differently. It's all how te relate to the story on a personal level. I personally loved Brooke & Peyton as friends, they had such a rapport. Such an innocent quality, yet at the same time so powerful.
Some fan of certain ships just hate Peyton, and wanted a reason to hate on her more, some wanted to hate on Brooke because LP is gone and the mostra is about BD now. Though not sure why they are watching if they hate Brooke. But anyway, it doesn't matter, the Brooke vs Peyton fight will go on long after we are all over it, and the mostra is over because their relationship was so strained.
I prefer to think of them as friends. little girls that grew up together and fell in Amore together, and grew into their friendship. And most of te know when having a gal friend it ain't all rosy and good times all the time. Most of it is full of arguments. And that is Breyton. Two girls who just happened at one time to Amore the same guy, and each other too.
I was IMMENSELY hurt da Brooke's words to Haley in 8x12, nor do I condone it. But I don't see a reason to fight with others over it, when their minds are clearly made up. I will always side with Brooke & Peyton, Lucas was for whom ever each wants. IMO I would never risk my friendship with my zappa for a guy, even a soulmate. But that is me.
I prefer not to take stock in an immature writer's drivel, than a 6 yr friendship. It's obvious that writers are human, and have opinions, I just don't agree with Fewell's opinion. She is one of a long string of bad choices the mostra has made for s8. I Amore the Brulian and Naley story, but the subplots need desperate work. Not sure if they are out of material, have writer's block, o out of inspiration. But something needs to be done.
We spent years with these two friends, only to have it end like this? No, I refuse to think of an "end" I think of it as a "time will tell" theory, and hold out hope. I am sure some ships hope più than I do for two silly High school girls being Friends again.
I loved that HB and LP moved on, but the worst part was the Breyton friendship being gone. Some people hate Peyton, some hate Brooke. I happened to Amore them both, hope te do too, no matter what side of the fence you're on.
