How would te have ended the movie?

I've just watched the movie!
I liked the movie ending. It gave us hope that John and Savannah ended up together and had their "happily ever after" :)
But the book ending was PERFECT! Sooooooo sad, but amazing and powerful. Especiaally the last scene when they are watching the moon replaying the moments they spent together knowing they won't see each other again... :(
It's good that there are different endings. Both are great in some ways...

I would have had the ending scene be John & Savannah getting married with Alan standing up as John's best man. =] I just think that would have been perfection.

i would end the moive da john gets married and they have a great life together! but how the moive ended sucked. ok they might be Friends again but still i think they should get married? who agrees with me!

I don't know. I just thought it was disappointing. I wanted to see what would happen later.

The way the book ended. Which was Tim survived and John never saw Savannah again. It was a sad ending, but that's how the original ended!

But I liked the ending, it let us imagine what would happen. I like when Film endings give a little hint as to what will happen successivo but it lets te imagine what would happen next.

"the book ending was PERFECT! Sooooooo sad, but amazing and powerful. Especiaally the last scene when they are watching the moon replaying the moments they spent together knowing they won't see each other again... :( "
so true..this is the perfect ending.:)

I hated the ending!! I would have john and savannah get married, allen would be the best man, and Tim survives, but is just Friends with savannah. <3 that movie though, it is such a sad movie!!!!!! :(