dibattito
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
dibattito Do te agree with the comment?(see in the commento section)
5 fans picked: |
|
I disagree
|
|||
|
I agree
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
Death results in the shutdown of all mental activities within the brain, including those that are required in order to have rights. Thus, if a dead man did not specify what he wanted to do with the body after death, the choice of the course of action should be left up to someone who is capable of making the decision (not necessarily family, as once the child reaches the age at whichhe can rationally consent to contracts he is no longer property (though he may reinstate the tiesto his family if he so desires)). The man, had he not made plans, essentially consented to whatever others desired,as dead men cannot claim to have rights (in cases when a living man makes plans for what will happen after his death, the dead man still has no rights. It is only the will of the cadaver a sit was in its living state that would prevent others from doing as they please, not anything inherent to thebody itself.)
If one wished, before death, that his body should be given to a certain person for certain purposes, it would be no different than one stating that he will hand money over if he dies. This can be broken down into the following form: If he does, in fact, die, he should give the entity heis dealing with the money that was agreed upon (through means other than the corpse rising to deliver the money, obviously). If he does not die, he is not obligated to give that entity anything (unless, of course, a separate contract was signed). Since the owner of the property with which the contract would be dealing with was able to consent and did do so, that consent is unwavering. It does not dissipate as soon as he dies. The present state of things does not change what the state ofthings was in the past, when the contract was agreed upon. Just as a log is not living, a corpseis not living, but the contracts signed by the rightful owner of these objects are not affected by that fact.'
accedi o registrati a fanpop per aggiungere il tuo commento