I always liked her with Sam but I guess Ryder is okay :)

I ship both Jarley and Ryley. but weirdly I'm starting to ship Ryley even more after to see Sadie Hawkins and Naked, I'm feel so bad for him :(

Not even going to answer this poll because this is like the 3rd or 4th time this question has been asked...

But to put it nicely...NO ONE. Marley should be with NOONE at this moment, in my opinion.

I love her with both but I am totally in Love with Jarley at the moment <3

Jake has proven how good he can be for her.. He truly loves her and she loves him back. For now, I think they should stay together and I hope they don't break up.. I really like them but I've learnt to not be too attached with couples as Glee just rips them apart and makes them go everywhere with anyone else. I did like her with Ryder briefly before though..

JAKE&MARLEY FOR LIFE!

Agreed Jake loves her and she loves him back, but he's not a good boyfriend, who got those amazing gifts for her? Ryder. Who gave her the best Valentine week for her? Ryder. So I don't like Jake, he's not a good boyfriend and is not at all like Puck because he made me laugh and Jake doesn't even do that :/

i agree with Clara_Valentina

okay, Ryder was a good listener but here seems to be the big thing that everyone is looking over..HE KISSED HIS FRIEND'S GIRLFRIEND! People focus on Jake using Ryder's ideas but we've all had a boyfriend or known a guy that doesn't really know what girls want. And yes Jake was pretty bad saying he was gonna get laid, but people forget another thing...THEY DIDN'T DO IT! HE NEVER FORCED HER! She said no and he said it was okay and cracked a joke. Why do people forget that?! And plus he's suppose to be Puck's brother, and that 'gonna get laid' line sounds like something Puck would say. If he did say it, it wouldn't be that big of a shock. Ryder knew he was wrong and he basically threw away his friendship the second he kissed Marley. I don't like him, even more so now for betraying his friend's trust, so I don't see in ANY way how Ryder is such a nice guy.....that felt good to let go. Yes I'm a Jarley fan but i do agree that Jake could have been better last episode.

Yes he did, he kissed his best friend's girlfriend but 3 people was blamer of that, first one Ryder of course, he souldn't, second is Jake because he accepted Ryder to help her with Marley knowing he loves her as much as he does, and third one is Marley, if she already made her desicion, she shouldn't have been with Ryder in that moment. I'm agree Jake's not blamer for not knowing what a girl likes but he shouldn't have used Ryder's ideas, he should have been himself and show his real intentions to her instane to get a hotel room. About Ryder throwing his friendship with Jake for Marley is not so important I guess because Jake also do that in the moment which he accepted date with her whitout think of his supposed 'best friend'.

This is the start of a great conversation...Okay Ryder offered his ideas for Jake to use. True Jake should have used some of his own at least once, but he had little confidence that he could do anything right for her. And Ryder's ideas were already working so he figured 'why mess up a good thing'. And again with the hotel room thing, he's PUCK'S YOUNGER HALF BROTHER. The guy told him to get lingerie as a gift! CLEARLY he's not a great go to person for advice when it comes to women. You expect it from Puck but not from Jake. But if you think about it, that hotel room thing was just a little nudge to remind us all he's A PUCKERMAN. And Marley went to Ryder to thank him for his gifts. She didn't expect to get kissed by her 'friend'. She's was being nice and Ryder was being TOO nice. And as for Jake going on a date with Marley, he was following his brother's advice. He was told to play it cool and she would come to him. And remember Jake TOLD Ryder in the next episode that he went out with her and asked him if he wanted him to back off of Marley and Ryder said NO. Clearly Ryder was in a tough spot and obviously said no when he did have a problem with it but still. Jake gave Ryder a chance to get with Marley when he asked him if he wanted him away from Marley because he didn't want to become 'mortal enemies' again. Jake thought of his friendship with Ryder before he continued seeing her.

^ haha IKR!
Yes I'm agree with that Ryder offered his ideas and Jake was unsure but he needs to be honest/himself if he wants to be on a relationship, besides when she told him that whatever is her gift she already loves it as she loves him, so I don't see why he would be worried about it. Maybe you're agree about Marley, she didn't expected that, even she should because she knew he liked her. Yes Ryder said he don't wanted him apart of Marley but what's supposedly he should have said Yes, can you please leave her alone, I don't want to see you with her' just not. Exacly both were friends so Ryder can't just have start a fight with him again. Besides there's the fact that Jake hurt Marley before and he suddely realized he loved her until he saw her with Ryder, so is like if she's not mine, then she won't be yours?

Glad to see we can laugh about this. Jake was attracted to her at first and they had that sweet moment on the bleachers. But do you remember how he beat up those two guys who were making fun of her mom after? That was pretty chivalrous of him. And he was clearly surprised by Kitty saying they were a couple. He really didn't know much about relationships and left Marley hurt. But Jake still talked with her and they had that sweet conversation at the lunch table where Brittany looked at them and called them 'young love'. They related with their similar backgrounds with both having single struggling moms with poor income. Jake didn't want Marley to leave him when they were at that lame Left Behind club AND broke up with Kitty when she was insulting Marley. Jake defended her too against Kitty, not just Ryder. Plus everyone loves to see jealousy bloom, it shows that he did like her enough to the point that he couldn't stand seeing another guy flirt with her. And I just want to bring this up into the discussion....why does everyone assume that after Ryder talked with Marley about her eating issue in the bathroom in 'GLEASE', that he CLEARLY was the one for her. He just made her laugh and then flirted with her. AND he decided to calm her nerves with a kiss, and he barely knew her that long! But then again all these couples fall hard faster than real people do. I do feel bad for Ryder and hope that the rumor that he'll be getting a new girl in the episode 'FEUD' is true.

Yes, always is better laugh than fight :)
I do remember that, they were so sweet on the bleachers and I loved when he defended her and her mom twice. I know he liked her since the begining but the point here is that for whatever reason he wasn't with her, when he broke up with Kitty in front of Marley and she asked him be the main role on the 'Grease' production with her, that could have been the right moment to getting closer with her, until a reasonable time have passed and so they could date, but he didn't because he thought he was too cool for a musical, I know he's a Puckerman and he supposedly should be like that but even Puck left the football team to be on the Glee club with Rachel and he wasn't even in love with her, so I guess Jake could have done an exception like his brother did, but he decided do that, once again, when he saw Ryder liked her and was aditioning for the main role. Yes, Ryder kissed Marley barely knowing her but Jake tried too, if you remember when Marley and Unique sang 'Womanizer' he asked her for a date just knowing her for like what? 5 seconds?, then when they hang out he tried to kiss her after their duet which was like 5 minutes to know her!, Ryder unlike spend a lot of time with her on the auditions for the musical and on the rehearse for it, so we that means they was good friends because obviously they didn't rehearsed 1 or 2 hours... Really? Ryder is going to have another girl? I really hopw that's not true! but I'm pretty sure it will be because Ryan is on team Jarley, so...

This is fun...okay yes jake had a chance to ask marley out after he dumped kitty but I guess he had to pull off the typical bad boy 'I'm too cool for this' attitude. Yes jake asked marley out after knowing her for a few seconds, but like the song said, he's...well was a womanizer. And at the bleachers they BOTH leaned in for a kiss but she pulled back. I'm not saying Ryder didn't spend time with her rehearsing but still...in that amount of time, can u really say it was a LITTLE too soon to kiss her considering they just met an episode ago and suddenly he kisses her. Jake got jealous we established this, but he wasn't just suddenly interested in marley because Ryder was, he was into her before. Sometimes it takes jealousy to realize it. Plus it seems to good to true that they both have similar backgrounds. Marley can relate to what he's going through. Okay Ryder's character was given a dyslexia disorder, but I don't know if he can really understand her as well as jake. Although he's obviously a good listener...lol. But jake not paying attention to marleys favorite flower isn't really enough of an argument to say he's not a good listener. How many people remember those nitpicky stuff? I do feel bad for ryder and hope he finds love......just not with marley

Haha yes, this is being fun :D
Exacty, that's a womanizer, but that doesn't mean he can do everything he wants and gets everything at the end (okay, yes it means that) that's not fair for another boys like Ryder. I don't think Jake have any problem, he says he has never feel like he belongs to anywhere because he's half-jewish, half-black and half-white but I don't think that's a serious problem, that sounds better like a joke, he gets always what he wants, he's just using that 'problem' as an excuse to don't have to show the real him. I'm agree with that, the fact that he doesn't remember Marley's favorite flowers doesn't mean he's not a good listener of boyfriend, that just means tht he maybe doesn't care about her enough as to know that, unlike Ryder, he's not even his boyfriend and he know everything about her, something that Jake doesn't. I hope Jake can be with Kitty at least once because they would be great together, also Marley with Ryder and then Jarley can endgame if Ryan wants, I can't do anything about it

I don't think he gets everything he wants. Yes he has Marley now, but before he was pining for her when she got close to Ryder. And when he saw them kiss during the Grease episode I felt bad for him. I'm not saying his whole half-black situation is a problem, i meant his single mom and poor income life is pretty bad. All we know about Ryder is that he has a dad that pushed him too hard when he was really dyslexic. I'm not saying he doesn't have any problems I mean Jake relates to her more. I want Marley to tell Jake the truth and to emphasize that HE kissed her. Jake will probably kick his ass for it and continue their feud. Maybe that's the reason the next episode is called 'FEUD'? Idk I'm just guessing. The whole Kitty thing was dumb because in the end they never really liked each other. THey were kind of like Puck and Santana. I hope Ryder feels bad that he kissed her and doesn't try to get with Marley if they break up because Jake found out. I mean that's really low. I kind of want to see them fight because i just remember how pissed Finn was when he found out that Quinn cheated on him with Puck and that she lied to him about the baby, and I can't imagine how pissed Jake's gonna be when he finds out. Finn doesn't have that much of a temper and he blew, imagine Jake.....I look forward to it, and hope Jarley doesn't break up.

I hope Jarley break up really soon, Jake deserves to be happy but Marley should be with Ryder, sorry Jake I really like you :(

I understand your reasoning Ryder's sweet but also kinda boring. He's fin 2.0. Marley and jake are a genuine yin yang couple that work do well together. They're like beauty and the beast or lady and the tramp. I love Disney movies lol! Ryder and her would be pretty dull. I want Ryder to have a girlfriend, just not marley. They've been built up since the first episode. I honestly think Ryder was just put in to create tension and show other options so jake wouldn't be an obvious choice. I was won with jarley the second I saw their performance on the bleachers. Don't know what's gonna happen but I think Ryder's gonna get his ass kicked when jake finds out what he did. Cant wait till the next episode!

^ I don't think Ryder is boring or a Finn 2.0, sure he's considered that but he has some actittudes that Finn doesn't and viceverse. Yes I love Disney movies too but the difference between them is that Beast wouldn't hurt Beauty and he truly loves her and she does too, though Marley doesn't love Jake because she doubt about her 'love' for him when Ryder kissed her and she always does. I also can't wait for the next episode either because 'Ryder will get his ass kicked' but Jake's going to lose Marley forever! So yeah I'm so happy!

I'm agree Clara <3

I like Marley with Ryder. Ryder loves Marley just as much as Jake does and it's killing Ryder to help Jake with Marley because Ryder loves her too. Who's the one who planned all the Valentine's Day gifts for Marley? Ryder. He would be so sweet to her. Jake is not a very good boyfriend for Marley and she deserves someone better, like Ryder.

^ This and what Clara said.

Ryley!!!! <333