Harry Potter vs Twilight

rispondi a questa domanda

Harry Potter vs Twilight Domanda

Have any Twilight fan (the hard-core, obsessive type) actually read 'Harry Potter'?

I think it's been asked before, but I thought I should just ask it for myself, to see what kind of responses I get. Because on this page, all the airheaded fan just state that "Eddie is hotter than Harry so suck shit and die". Like, what? Is that SUPPOSED to be a debate? And, um, if anyone thinks Robert Pattinson is più attractive, has anyone even SEEN Dan in 'Equus'? o Alan Rickman, for that matter? That's beside the point.

I just want to know if any Twitard has read all the HP libri so they can actually compare the two series. :D
 sleazy_weasley posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight Risposte

tooch said:
I really, really do Amore Twilight, but I know where the line is and where we all need to stop.
I'm not overly obsessive like some. I enjoy a healthy dibattito about the two. And I try not to waste my time with the unintelligent ones (even though they drive me mad, and I have to say something).

Yes, I have read the Harry Potter series. Twice over, and I have throughly enjoyed. Its amazing! Unique . . . and my gosh, how could te not Amore it! J.K Rowling has some imagination, just mindblowing.

There is so much più detail in the Harry Potter books, compared to Twilight. I think the Twilight Series would have been better if it wasn't written in Bella's point of view. I know that that would be somewhat weird and messed up, but it would stop us having to read parts where Bella is just drooling over Edward, etc. I think that's one factor about why people say that book is written badly, and whatnot.

Well, that's me. I Amore both series :)
 select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Thank you! One of the sane Twilight fans, I see. :)
sleazy_weasley posted più di un anno fa
*
but still if te had to pick one which would it be?
lokhart posted più di un anno fa
valao said:
I`m a obsessed Twilight fan and I`ve read all the Harry Potter libri including The tales of Beedle the Bard and one più which name i`m not sure about. I can say Harry Potter started fine - nice story, great actor selection for the Film - i started liking Alan Rickman, Jason Isaacs and David Thewlis because of the Harry Potter movies. BUT there`s a huge, enormous mistake that made me HATE Harry Potter - the illogical happy ending. I wanted Voldemort to win because too many preferito characters died for Harry. Now i like Twilight più - the story goes slow, smooth and everything has a reason. Twilight is much better than Harry Potter even though Stephanie says she can`t be compared to Rowling because Rowling`s better. Not true. It`s just that Harry Potter was the first to awake the passive reader community. It`s because of being first, that`s all the noise about. That`s what i think.
 select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I dont think that the ending was illogical tbf, it made sense (and it would have been a right arse if HP died, because it would end in an awkward story ending I think) . Also, I think Jo did it in an inventive way, rather than what everyone expected. But, hey, thats just my personal opinion :) x
Italktosnakes posted più di un anno fa
*
Ilogical ending is the phrase I would use to describe Twilight, but te at least know WHAY te don`t like HP. :)
ilovereading posted più di un anno fa
*
yeah. i agree with ilovereading as to describing Twilight, but i'd say i also hoped Voldie would win. but after he killed Snape, i don't think i cared. HP doesnt make sense without the Ehhhhhvil Potions Master. oh, sorry, Ex-Potions Master.
vskparaimer posted più di un anno fa
VampiresRevenge said:
Yes, this domanda has already been asked, and Twilight fan did give answers. I have no idea if any hard-core, obsessive ones did, though.

Why has no one asked a domanda about if all of the HP fan in this spot have read Twilight? There was even a pick where I saw that some HP fan haven't read Twilight, so why is it that this domanda is always asked, and not one for HP fans?

And calling them "airhead" fan is not going to score te any points with any Twilight fan nor will it increase your chances of them answering this domanda without throwing an insult at you.

Oh, and I do think that Robert Pattinson is hotter, but that's just my opinion, just like Alan and Dan being hotter is your opinion. And I have seen how Dan looks in Equus and I have seen Alan. You're recitazione like anyone who likes Rob più is wrong.

To answer your question, I have read every single one of the libri and have seen all of the movies, but should I really answer this domanda if I'm not a hard-core, obsessive type?
 select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Agreeing. I have read both series and I dunt reli know if i am hard core o absessive either ?? Humm
a-jforever posted più di un anno fa
*
Obsessive sorry
a-jforever posted più di un anno fa
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
we have read twilight it is good but it is not able to stand in front of harry potter & why the hell are we debating on two completely different libri with different storyline and genre
lokhart posted più di un anno fa
mitchie19 said:
I'm a Twilight fan and I only read one Harry Potter book. I randomly started Leggere in book 5 because my parents bought it for me the time I told them to buy me any book.
I also liked the movies. They're great too, also the book.

I choose both. Both authors did a great job.
I guess, Its just me.



:)
 select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Oh! te should try and read the other books, then, so then te know what happens! ;) Otherwise te might not get the story. But I appreciate your opinion. :)
sleazy_weasley posted più di un anno fa
*
Thank you!! :)
mitchie19 posted più di un anno fa
*
*Spoiler!* te read the book Sirius died in?! Dx!
TeamSiriusBlack posted più di un anno fa
*
i advise te - read the libri from the beginning. te know, i started with part 6. just warning. i was wondering for pretty long time who Bellatrix Lestrange was.
vskparaimer posted più di un anno fa
topazEYEs91 said:
ive read all the hp book and i Amore them a lot, ive always watched the Film but i first read the libri a few months ago... i dont like comparing twilight and hp togeather because they are both very different, i dont know why ppl Amore to compare the two togeather, but everyone has their opinion... and i dont really care who is "hotter" i actually like both of the stories and characters, not just the looks... i dont think that was a "airheaded" response...
 select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
I agree. Some ppl are just not into that type of thing.
HOU0007 posted più di un anno fa
HOU0007 said:
Yes, yes I have. And I liked it. That's why I go for both Twilight and Harry potter Peoples.lol!
 select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
well yes im the really obsesssive type and i hat that people always say like make commenti thinking oh they havent read harry potter thats why they only like twilight well guess wat people i have read every single harry potter book and watched every single movie!!!! plus i think harry potter is kind of cute! and im obsessvie . im a twilight fan i read both . i guess its thats just me!?
Taylormyhottie posted più di un anno fa
*
^Some people also don't like it when Twilight fan say HP haven't read Twilight. people constantly tell me that at school even though i have :/ And not many HP fan have detto that, becuase we know I a lot of people who have read both, like VampiresRevenge (King of the Lab!)
TeamSiriusBlack posted più di un anno fa
*
yea i totally agree
topazEYEs91 posted più di un anno fa
chagrin91 said:
Lolxx i have and to be honest i was obsessed with it may be i still am as i am anxiously waiting for HP and the deathly hallows movie. and i live Hp it is i think da far the best magical stories i have read and i Amore it and my fav book is HP and the order of phoenix it is just soooo good i really miss HP now coz of twilight and i myself am soo busy with HW and stuff i dnt have time to read it but i surely will and FYI i dont read HP so that i can bash on hp fan its flaws coz i read it for the fun of it the joy it brings with itself is magical lolxxx
 select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!