Both are just as creepy, but I chose this one because of the fact that the stalkee liked being creeped on.

She's a teenage girl and a ghost, they saw it coming.

... I don't watch Twilight. Cause, I prepare watching HP instead Twilight. To me, Twilight sucks!!

She saw them naked.. That's creepy and disgusting.
Most of the time, Bella was aware of him watching and she wanted him there.
I doubt any of them wanted Myrtle to watch them bathe.

^Lmao. if they did want the little kid ghost girl watching them, they're pervs

Robert Pattinson (Edward) wanted her to watch him? :O Just joking x]

Even if Bella wanted him there, she still didn't find out about it for a while. And even if she DID want him there, the general concept is creepier, I mean, he basically stalked her, and broke into her house. HOW could someone think that's ROMANTIC?

^ Exactly. That's creepy, not romantic. I could understand if she gave him permission to stay in her room and watch her sleep, but violating her privacy BEFORE they were a couple? That's just wrong.

They shoulda at least expected some of the ghosts woulda been...curious.

And, come on, HE BROKE INTO HER HOUSE!
Creepy,
Watching someone sleep without their knowledge is freaky.
And what kind of weirdo THINKS IT'S ROMANTIC.

Harry had the right reaction at least.

^LOL Yeah he did! Bella was just like "OMG Eddykins how sweet! I luvs U even more now!"

Ew, I just gagged a little even writing that, :P

And how did he break into her house and no one noticed?? He's been doing it for how long? Jeeze, great cop you are Charlie .__.

Best cop in the world, amirite?

Totally. VERY perceptive, huh?

Oh, I agree.

How did he even break into her house in the first place? Did she keep her windows open? I'm sure most people lock their windows and doors every night. What did he do? Steal Bella's house key and made a copy for himself? Stalker!

Climbed into her window, from what I read in the book from his POV.
Since it's on the second story, I think, no need to lock it so... *shrugs*
Aren't vampires supposed to be invited into places though?
The fuck, Smeyer?

You're reading the Edward POV book? Is it as bad as the original Twilight?

You read Midnight Sun? The horror! x] I live in a 2 story house and I still lock my doors and close my windows (sorry, it's not the sliding open kind that Bella has lol). What did he do? Run up the side of the house and climb in, or climb a tree and jump across? :p

No, I read some of it online.
He climbed into her window, if I remember correctly.

No, it's worse!
Oh god, when he went on about something about crushing killing the kids in his bio class after meeting Bella for the first time, and getting all creepy I made a "D:" face and stopped reading.

SO. MUCH. WRONG. WITH. THAT. BOOK.

So much wrong with the whole 'sigh-ga' >_<

^LOL I agree. And killing everyone in Biology class? That's just psychotic. And all because of some stupid Mary Sue. Pathetic.

I mean, he was going on about how tasty and tempting her blood was, and how he'd have to kill everyone if he decided to suck her blood. Witnesses and all that jazz.

Oh dear god it was horrifying!

He wanted to kill kids (yes, kids) just because they fancied Bella? WTF? Damn you SMeyer! You really wanted to make Edward a monster didn't you?

No, I get what she was getting at.

He was more or less thinking:

"Well, fuck, if I kill her I'd have to kill them too. Can't have everyone freaking out! Hell, I might have to kill the whole school!"


*shudders*

Then he really does have no sense of control. If I were Carlisle, I'd banish him from the family, then he would have no choice but to move to Alaska with the Denali clan x]

I could see how that /could/ make sense, not wanting witnesses, but srsly, this is aimed at teenage girls.
What. The. Hell.

The other one isn't CREEPY. That isn't the right word to describe it.

^ Perverted maybe?

But this is Stephenie Meyer writing. Only the bad guys die, remember? She couldn't have innocent humans die or it will ruin her perfect fantasy book.

I'm off to bed guys. Good night Ven and Kate. I'll be back tomorrow. Peace.

Night!
Wait, people /die/ in her books?
That wasn't a character that had literally had a handful of lines?
What is this i don't even

Goodnight! See you!

Irina died in BD, remember? And it was for some stupid reason too....Typical SMeyer.

She was killed for some reason I don't even remember.
But she didn't even exist for an entire chapter and she was killed off.
Then had a book made about her.
-_-

Irina? What book? I can't believe SMeyer's writing even MORE Toilet...I mean Twilight. Seriously, enough is enough! She's giving books a bad name.

The short second life of Bree Tanner is the name of the book.
:/

Oh. That's a different one then. I mean Irina from the Alaska family, I think Caius killed her because she was wrong about the satan spawn..I mean Renesmee, or something like that.
Still though, ew. Twilight is just ew.

Oh, yeah, she got killed too, didn't she?
Man, wtf, she made a mistake, let it go dude.

Bioth are creepy but I choose this one because it was going on for months where as Myrtle only watched Harry take a bath once.

This is creepy ! xS
Myrtle was trying to watch Harry through the bubbles! Ewww xP

Both.
But.....Harry was offended by Myrtle trying to watch him,and Bella approved Edward's stalking (just like the other abusive characteristics).
But I can say that Myrtle was just weird too....

Both are creepy, but the fact that Edward watching Bella sleep without her knowledge was made to seem romantic makes it creepier.

Who hasn't seen Dan Radcliffe naked at some point? XD

But seriously, this is a tough one. Harry was actually naked, whilst Bella was probably under her duvet with pyjamas on. But then, she liked being stared at. That's pretty creepy.

Ahem Bella wasn't naked at least.

Edward's DEFINATELY creepy, and what he did was wrong, but someone watching you bathe, and you can't do anything about it...*shudders* At least with Edward you can tell him to fuck off and he'd probably listen (there's a 65% chance).

Myrtle must get lonely sometimes in those bathrooms :)

Besides, Bella is ASLEEP at the time, how does she know what Edward does?

@youknowit: Not really. Myrtle might be a teenage ghost, but they are all teenagers too and considering how many years Myrtle has been dead I guess she's kind of older than them.

I think both are equally creepy, but Myrtle only did it once. It doesn't justify it, or anything, I just think it's worse that Edward did it several times.

although mrytles a ghost
but watching someone showerin is distubing

Come on! She's the ghost of the bathrooms. Of course she's going to snoop around the prefect's bathroom.

However, Edward trespassed Bella's territory.

at least she only did that once, and he knew she was there lol.