What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

One albero collina Do te think it was right for peyton to punch, punzone brooke in season 4 ep. 14 because she sleeps with nathan (peyton and nathan broked up and brooke was drunk)?????

79 fans picked:
yeap! i think it was right!
   63%
no way!what she did it was whorse!
   37%
 roxylovesbrucas posted più di un anno fa
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

29 comments

user photo
LauraRocks picked yeap! i think it was right!:
i dont know i would have do it to though so thats why i chose this!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
loves-oth picked yeap! i think it was right!:
roxylovesbrucas you clearly don't think she should have...
your question's wording is SO BIAS!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
SG1-090 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
YEH! IT was so awesome! Brooke's face, Peyton's face, Peyton's punch! LMAO Peyton's got a swing on her! =D
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
abs07 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
***rolls eyes***
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
oth-rocks-23 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
i'm a brucas fan and i still think it was right!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Angelika picked yeap! i think it was right!:
of course it was!!!!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
ritergrl picked yeap! i think it was right!:
TOTALLY was!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
roxylovesbrucas picked no way!what she did it was whorse!:
yes guys you are right...i totally think she souldn't have!! maybe because i'm a big brucas fan...but brooke was really drunk and amazing...she still ask nathan if he and peyton broke up....i think this means something!!!anywere the peyton's punch was to much....!!!! maybe she sould remember what she done!!!:P:P...anywere thanks for picks!!!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
BRUCASBELIEVER picked yeap! i think it was right!:
I think the punch was okay because she had just found out and she was in shock but having a grudge later about it was dumb because she did way worse, Brooke loved Lucas both times Peyton broke them up and Neyton was just sex and fighting!!!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurra picked yeap! i think it was right!:
THATS WHAT SHE SAID!!!! LMAO S! ;)
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurra picked yeap! i think it was right!:
btw im sick of this pick :) k thanks!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
ritergrl picked yeap! i think it was right!:
That's what she said XDD
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Jeez i thought we have moved passed this i refuse to answer this pick
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Leyton4ever picked yeap! i think it was right!:
well first off being drunk is not an excuse for anything...and two nathan and peyton broke up and got back together all the time...brooke was out of line...end of story
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurencia7 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
LOL once again the Peyton vs Brooke monster rolls it's fugly head...LOL, will it ever end!?

*Laurencia cried, running off into the distance, her hair matted from pulling at it.*

I love Peyton, I love Brooke...but yes, Brooke deserved it, only a little it was more about LISTEN Brooke being nasty to Peyton about her mom than NATHAN she could have cared less about Nate...she was just mad at Brooke, and it had been built up for a long time.

Brooke, knew...and she apologized for real after Peyton hit her...so once again Breyton lives through another disastrous event.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurencia7 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
THE END!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
roxylovesbrucas picked no way!what she did it was whorse!:
It's just a pick...why can you get over it....say yes or not...and if you are sick of this pick...don't answer....I will not kill you if you don't...and i mention that brooke was drunk and peyton and nathan brooke up because i've seen this pick in another site and everybody says.....woow...how can brooke do that to peyton..to his boyfriend...sow i was just reminding you...is a pick...sow pick yes or not...and this is it...nobody want's to start the fight again( with uot jokes) but this doesn't meant that i've got to love peyton if i don't only to be peace...i wanna know what you guys think about the drama of that episode...clearly??
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurra picked yeap! i think it was right!:
i dont understand you


THAT IS WHAT SHE SAID!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
ritergrl picked yeap! i think it was right!:
It's just a pick...why can you get over it....say yes or not...and if you are sick of this pick...don't answer....I will not kill you if you don't...and i mention that brooke was drunk and peyton and nathan brooke up because i've seen this pick in another site and everybody says.....woow...how can brooke do that to peyton..to his boyfriend...sow i was just reminding you...is a pick...sow pick yes or not...and this is it...nobody want's to start the fight again( with uot jokes) but this doesn't meant that i've got to love peyton if i don't only to be peace...i wanna know what you guys think about the drama of that episode...clearly??

Hmmmm... that's what she said


yet I'm finding trouble comphrehending (that's what she said!)
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
just_leyton picked yeap! i think it was right!:
ok have many years you have?because really brooke deserves that sleep,1 of all peyton said to brooke that she has feelings for lucas ,but brooke never told peyton that she slept with nathan
but hey brooke was young,she was like a whore in 1 season(not to be rude,but she was acting like that,and besides she is adult person now,and she is not the same brooke davis ..we all now that,and that"s why i love brooke
peyton and brooke the best:D
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
alessandra_28 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
roxylovesbrucas imagine your best friend and your ex boyfriend having sex 5 minutes after you broke up...I bet you would punch her if that happens.

and please enough of this questions!!
posted più di un anno fa.
last edited più di un anno fa
 
user photo
abs07 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
yeah roxy, I'm not gonna repeat my last long schpeel about this "legendary" topic but I'll make a new short one: it's not simply what brooke did - it was the hypocrisy behind it. Don't forget what brooke put peyton through for not being honest the first time around - then what brooke put peyton through when she was ACTUALLY honest - she treated her 10 times worse when peyton actually LISTENED and was honest the 2nd time around with no intention of "stealing lucas". Brooke on the other hand was DISHONEST and had no intention of BEING honest. Do you not see the hypocrisy behind brooke's "stand" about honorable honesty? Watch that 415 scene again when peyton explains why she was so bitterly angry: link

maybe you should remember...
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurra picked yeap! i think it was right!:
lmao! abs you do realise your the only one who bothers with explaining this anymore? we all started out .. then stop when we realise there never gonna listen! NOT YOU! i admire that! :) i really cba with this anymore. i believe what i believe. she believes was she believes! difference is ... what i believe is righT HAH! :)
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurra picked yeap! i think it was right!:
thats what she said! :)
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
abs07 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
lol, laurra, :P

I don't bother reexplaining it to the same people unless I have anything new to add - but with people I haven't debated with before, I usually give a small blurb of why I stand where I stand - I can't help it :P
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Laurra picked yeap! i think it was right!:
lol bless! :) - if they wanna know my opinion theyll have go and search for it XD


which is not hard. they can find these repeat picks anywere.
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
alex_sandra picked no way!what she did it was whorse!:
Well, I don't think that it was right, but I can understand her, that was painful to see this video... But to be honest, I didn't get why she was so mad?? She dated with the boy whom she loves!! It's her dream! Nathan was a nightmare for her!!!
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
RoXanne4Brucas picked no way!what she did it was whorse!:
Hmmm...I think she was worng but I think what Peyton did it was wrost
posted più di un anno fa.
 
user photo
Bangel90 picked yeap! i think it was right!:
I think that being mad and caught up in the moment, I would've reacted the same way (maybe not with a punch but I'd be pissed off). Then after I'd cooled down I'd realize: Brooke slept with Nathan when they were both really drunk and it was a one-time thing of course and Peyton and Nathan weren't in a relationship at the time so those are two different things.
posted più di un anno fa.