I was just rewatching the episode where Brooke and Peyton get into a fight so I was just thinking about which one of the girls I would not like to get into a fight with. I think it would be Peyton becuase Brooke is more of a verbal attack kind of girl. Haley is more of the slapping girl. Where Peyton is the girls who tackles you and pulls your hair. So I would hate to get into a fight with her.

Brooke is crazyyyy when shes angry and when she gets into fights lol

^^^ but i agree Haley is the slaper and Peyton is more of the pulling but I still would hate to get in a fight with Brooke :P

Peyton is vicious when she's angry! She's always been the one to initiate the physical fighting with Brooke. on the way to the state championship, she slapped Brooke first in the car after Brooke talked about her dead moms, she tackled Brooke in her yard, and she punched Brooke and gave her a black eye after finding out about the sex tape that Brooke made with Nathan

so yeah, I'd definitely try to stay on peytons good side lol

Yeah also I noticed that almost all the fights Peyton got into she started with a tackle.

Brooke definitely knows how to hit you where it hurts with her words, but Peyton is a beast lol. Whether it's Brooke, Nikki, or psycho Derek... Peytons definitely not afraid to kick some ass lol. I'd much rather be hurt by words, than hurt by a fist!

^totally agree. brooke is the best @ hurting with words. haley is THE bitch slapper. and peyton is the tackling, hairpulling one. haha. LOL.

Peyton's a bad ass! :P

I'm pretty sure I could own any of them in a fight, lol.

All of them really, I guess I'm thinking about the long term effects, I wouldn't want to be enemies with any of these girls because their all really awesome but I guess if I was worried about which girl would break my nose, I'd go with Peyton.

I guess because I've been in quite a few fights, it's not the physical that i worry about anymore. I'm an emotional person and I'm not even gonna lie, i get more hurt over cruel things being said to me. Hell, a few of my fights started with bitches talking a bunch of nonsense and I eventually got so upset that it came to blows!

I wouldn`t mess with Brooke. That`s for SURE.

She knows how to fight!
Just look at psycho Derek!

Peyton could know me around that's for sure..lol

She's crazy, really.

I can't really imagine myself fighting with Brooke or Haley, really. xD So i guess i have to pick Peyton for that reason too. lol

I wouldn't wanna fight with any of them, i think we would go along =) So I'm not picking =)

hahahaha i WOULD LOVE to fight peyton!

Brooke's da bitch.

how about Nikki?