Peyton gets praised for the good she does, and gets hated for the bad(sometimes way too much and for no reason) but out of all the characters she's deffenetly the most perfectly rated.

I would have said Brooke between Brooke and Peyton, but people still like Brooke as the zombie/Sophia version of her...so that's a mystery to me. Brooke and Peyton probably get the most hate and the most love, and rightfully so.

1.Brooke
2.Peyton

Yup. Brooke is overrated. Nathan is overrated. Lucas is underrated. Haley is underrated. That's my view.

Nathan & Peyton.

or Peyton

I don't think anyone can argue that the fans let Peyton get away with anything bad she's done :') Unlike Brooke who could get away with murder.
I completely agree with energizerbunny...Lucas and Haley are way underrated.

how come Brooke is both over and perfectly rated????LOL....anyway i completely agree that Brooke and Nate are overrated Hales and Luke are underrated and Peyton is perfectly rated becayse as xloverlyyx said Peyton fans (incuding me) recognize her mistakes and dont think she is PERFECT 100%...we know her flaws and we know her strenghts....we may find her perfect BUT without ignoring her mistakes...she is what she is and we judge her, i believe, objectively (unlike IMO Brooke)

brooke she so onverrated the writers that think she THE main charater but she not, it lucas