At the church, Paige was approached da Piper and Phoebe, who told her that, like Prue, she had the power to sposta objects with her mind: Telekinesis. Skeptically, Paige tried to sposta a candle da waving her hand at it, and failed. While saying that she must not be one of them if she could not make a candle move, she gestured at it again, and the candle disappeared from its stand and reappeared in her hand. Paige soon learned she could orb objects da calling for them verbally.She was then approached da a Source-possessed Shane, claiming someone was hunting him. She left with him, fleeing the sisters. The fonte of All Evil then took Paige back to her place where he tempted her to use her powers to kill the man who she thought was abusing his child. Paige tried to kill the man da calling out his heart, but Phoebe and Piper were able to stop her and Leo orbed her to the Halliwell home. It was discovered that the man was innocent and it was his wife who was abusing the child. The fonte of All Evil then dealt a mortal blow to Cole, leaving him to die slowly. Back at the manor Paige threw a fit, and The fonte of All Evil attacked them. The fonte of All Evil tried to tempt her into choosing evil, but she chose to be with her sisters when The fonte attacked Phoebe. The fonte then boasted of killing Cole and tried to kill a police inspector who was spying on the sisters, but the inspector was saved da the healing powers of Leo Wyatt. The sisters and Leo then found Cole and were able to use the combined powers of Leo and Paige to heal him. Paige then reconciled with her sisters, but Shane, having jumbled memories of his possession, broke up with her. Phoebe and Piper then took her back to their home and used a spell to summon the spirit of Patricia Halliwell to reunite the long separated mother and daughter.
