[Chorus 1:]
Why would te wanna break a perfectly good heart?
Why would te wanna take our Amore and tear it all apart,now?
Why would te wanna make the very first scar?
Why would te wanna break a perfectly good heart?

Maybe I should've seen the signs, should've read the Scrivere on the wall.
And realized da the distance in your eyes that I would be the one to fall.
No matter what te say, I still can't believe
That te would walk away.
It don't make sense to me, but:

[Repeat Chorus 1:]
Why would te wanna break a perfectly good heart?
Why would te wanna take our Amore and tear it all apart, now?
Why would te wanna make the very first scar?
Why would te wanna break a perfectly good heart?

It's not unbroken anymore.
How do I get it back the way it was before?

[Chorus 2:]
Why would te wanna break a perfectly good heart?
Why would te wanna take our Amore and tear it all apart,now?
Why would te wanna make the very first scar?
Why would te wanna break, would te wanna break a:

[Repeat Chorus 1:]
Why would te wanna break a perfectly good heart?
Why would te wanna take our Amore and tear it all apart, now?
Why would te wanna make the very first scar?
Why would te wanna break a perfectly good heart?