I used to love these two... but they've gone so far downhill IMO, that I honestly had a hard time choosing either option at this point. I've always felt like their story in general is very rushed, and repetitive. But I do think that their chemistry in the beginning of their story was pretty great.

I kinda love them more and more even if they can be a bit boring at times. I just couldn't choose the other option. Their chemistry is quite great, I just prefer the story even she's not perfect.

I mostly agree with kellyerin87.
I think their story was very rushed and kind of just ran in circles (especially with the fighting and making up in almost every episode of seasons 6 and 7). I feel like if a couple has been around for almost 4 seasons (6,7,8,and 9)- then I should have seen their relationship change and develop dramatically over that time. But I feel like the strength of Brooke & Julian's relationship hasn't really changed since the end of season 6. And that's not to say it's not strong... in fact I think the problem is that it was TOO strong at the beginning (I mean Julian said he loved her after just a few weeks and wanted her to move away with him after a month). I feel like they were just as in love in season 7 and could have gotten married then, the writers just waited til season 8 to give us something to look forward to. But in general I think their story is fine- I just think that their chemistry is the reason I love them.
At times they have had amazing chemistry and other times it's just been okay. But it was definitely their chemistry in season 6 that drew me to them.