rispondi a questa domanda

Cristianesimo Domanda

this a weird qns! but i really honestly wanna know??

hi! i was just wondering.. is masterburating a sin?? like for both boy and girls
*
also note, i'm not planning to do it.. it just crossed my mind..
alisonfaith297 posted più di un anno fa
 alisonfaith297 posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Cristianesimo Risposte

Cinders said:
This domanda is thoroughly discussed on link, where te will see varying perspectives on the topic, Bible citations, and logic arguments that might help answer your question. You'll even find my opinion there, as te will in several places on this site. But here it is again for you:

A) Sexual repression leads to violence, frustration, anger, and feelings of inadequacy. This is a social fact, documented da study. Don't believe me? Terrorists are very, very, unbelievably sexually repressed (that's the extreem).

B) Other creatures, such as bonobos, masturbate and have sex to relieve tension in social groups. As a result, the bonobos do not have "wars" like their cousins, the chimpanzees, because they have completely replaced violence with sex.

C) From an anthropological standpoint, it is unhealthy (not just for the emotional/psychological reasons mentioned in A, but for physical reasons) not to have sexual release. If te do not have a partner, masturbation is the clearest solution.

D) From a societal standpoint, it is unusual for someone NOT to masturbate.

In conclusion, I do not believe that God would want us engaging (or in this case, participating in a vow of non-engagement) in an activity that is actually detrimental to our health and growth not only as individuals, but as a species.

EDIT: In addition, the Bible says it is a sin to "spill your seed" needlessly, correct? Once again, the misogyny of the Old World saves the woman from any crime in this area. ;o) Ladies, have at it! te have no seed to spill.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Poseidon3 said:
I honestly don't see why it'd be a sin. Its not hurting you, nor is it hurting anyone else. It doesn't have the qualities of a sin.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
thanks i was just wondering.
alisonfaith297 posted più di un anno fa
*
Yeah, I agree.
SouthParkSmart posted più di un anno fa
SouthParkSmart said:
Nope, it's not in my opinion. You're going to get all kinds of risposte on this club, but it really is not a sin.

The Hebrew Bible forbids masturbation (well, the story of Onan is debatable about whether o not it was actually about masturbation) because people at that time thought men "spilling their seed" was the only way a baby could be made. They didn't know about eggs and stuff. So they basically thought it was wasting your kids, lol.

Masturbation also has a lot of health benefits, and God wouldn't make something that was wrong AND good for you.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
TeamSongz4eva said:
heh i was wondering that too..but im catholic and they detto it was a sin:/ im still not sure why???
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »