rispondi a questa domanda

Il Signore degli Anelli Domanda

Are there any religions like Cristianesimo & Atheism among the people of Middle-Earth?

 spikes_girl posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Il Signore degli Anelli Risposte

i_luv_angst said:
I don't think so....The existence of Iluvatar and the Valar, Ainur, and Maia, (who are rather god-like since they created Middle-Earth and its inhabitants), is più of a fact that everyone accepts than a religion that only some people believe in.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Elizabeth0 said:
I think not. But I am sure that people of M.E. beleve in good and bad forces. Just like Gandalf detto in FOTR: "So do all who live to see such times, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time we are given. There are other forces at work in the world than the will of evil."

select as best answer
 I think not. But I am sure that people of M.E. beleve in good and bad forces. Just like Gandalf detto in FOTR: "So do all who live to see such times, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time we are given. There are other forces at work in the world than the will of evil."
posted più di un anno fa 
staplesnout said:
Middle-Earth is a monotheist world (not pagan!) before coming of Christ. There are strong structural parallels between Eru and God the Creator, the Valar and Maiar and angelic powers (or "gods" in Plato's Timaios dialogue, which are not the same as the Creator - they can form the world only according to His design), Melkor and Lucifer, fall of Numenor and the Deluge (but te can't tell that these parallels are direct analogies with Cristianesimo o allegories, since te can find such parallels in other myths too, not only in the Bible). It's like the Old Testament, but in perception of other culture than judaic-christian, therefore differences in details. Tolkien's hierarchic image of the world and his presentation of Good and Evil (the Evil is not substantial at last) reminds the (neo)platonic one, it is especially clearly seen in Ainulindale, the first part of the Silmarillion.

In The Lord of the Rings there are not so many mentions of these things, but for example Denethor's and Gandalf's contraposition of -heathen- kings of old and their contemporary situation is not without purpose (it implicates that their world is alredy not heathen). On the other hand, it looks like these beliefs are not very institutionalized (there are no temples and priests mentioned), so te can't call them a real religion.

In general, it seems to me very interesting how Tolkien showed us how many structures are common for different myths and how many bounds connect us (christians o post-christians) with the people of old actually (and that many old cultures were much più than primitive pagans).
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Blossom71 said:
I think più like pagan religion.But the battle between good and evil would suggest christian.I guess it's how te want to see it.
select as best answer
 I think più like pagan religion.But the battle between good and evil would suggest christian.I guess it's how te want to see it.
posted più di un anno fa 
kuykendall said:
Yes Christianity. How? Sauron is thought of as Luicfer and Gandalf as God. I think that's how my Youth Pastors wife explained it to me.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Tolkien detto the book is not allegorical, that he disliked allegory, so your pastor's wife is mistaken. C.S. Lewis, on the other hand, did weave his Cristianesimo into his books.
duinrandir posted più di un anno fa
next question »