Wats better libri o films sondaggio Results - Il Signore degli Anelli

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Il Signore degli Anelli Wats better libri o films

383 fans picked:

film

61%

book

39%

lionsheather posted più di un anno fa

Make your pick! | next poll >>

48 comments

	lionsheather picked book: Personnaly i fell in love with the books well before the films :P posted più di un anno fa.

	miiamya picked film: it was really really really hard to choose posted più di un anno fa.

	Charmape picked film: To be honest I never read the books so... posted più di un anno fa.

	DrDevience picked film: I read the books over and over... There are quite a few dry spots in them. So, as much as I do love them in spite of their faults, I liked the movies a wee bit better. posted più di un anno fa.

	lionsheather picked book: this is interesting wasnt expecting this! Movie was brillent my only complaint was how hobbits were protrayed but overall i think the movies are outstanding...but nowhere close to the books posted più di un anno fa.

	Quinzark picked book: BOOKS FTW posted più di un anno fa.

	wiccan666 picked book: Are you kidding me! Books are always better than movies! there the originals and they have a 1000 more details! posted più di un anno fa.

	iar picked book: The books are a 1000 better than the movies because of the details and because you can imagine the things in the way you want or you feel. I always prefer a book better than a movie. posted più di un anno fa.

	CharmedAngel88 picked book: I love the movies, but the books are so much better! posted più di un anno fa.

	thill14 picked book: books definitly there are millions more details posted più di un anno fa. last edited più di un anno fa

	pingu picked film: the book is better but its 2 spaced out. tolkien said it could never be made into a good film but alas they have! well done cast n crew films 12 hrs 2 watch books 12 weeks 2 read posted più di un anno fa.

	pingu picked film: it should b 50-50 posted più di un anno fa.

	Shaluna picked book: Book! I like the movies also though. I'm suprised to see that movies are "winning". posted più di un anno fa.

	shieldmaiden picked film: the films actually in holding attention. i had to push myself through the first book and didn't really get into the trilogy until the second book posted più di un anno fa.

	edwardcullen23 picked book: The books are the films in more detail. The books also are what the movies are based on. The movies can't be the best because they aren't the best the people could have done. posted più di un anno fa.

	knitink picked book: The absence of Tom Bombadil in the films was disappointing. Also, Tolkein spelled "Wats" like this: "What's." posted più di un anno fa.

	RainbowGeek819 picked film: LOOOOOOOOOOOOVE THE MOVIESS it would be my fav movies but... I HATE THE ENDING!! you dont get told what happens to legolas!!?!?! But i know what happens anyway! which is sad...! posted più di un anno fa.

	xElvenPiratex picked film: I like the movies better for the simple reason that it ends on a much more hopeful note. Even though it's sad, you know everyone is going to be okay. The ending of the book is probably more realistic, but it's just too melancholy for me. Also, I think Tolkien did a wonderful job of creating new worlds and languages and people, but overall, I believe PJ is a better story teller. posted più di un anno fa. last edited più di un anno fa

	i_luv_angst picked book: you would find out what happened to legolas, and gimli, and merry, and pippin, sam, aragorn, and eomer if you read the appendices in the books posted più di un anno fa.

	spikes_girl picked film: i haven't read the books cuz my friends tell me there's all this stuff they changed so i'd probably just get confused. :) posted più di un anno fa.

	king_wa picked book: movies are rarely better than the books. posted più di un anno fa.

	alvinseville picked book: the book has more detail posted più di un anno fa.

	RaNmAlUvRr12 picked film: I haven't read the book yet so..... posted più di un anno fa.

	swimswamswum picked book: The book was defintely better than the movies. Both were true masterpieces, but the books were just OMG. posted più di un anno fa. last edited più di un anno fa

	Elizabeth0 said: I aready made pick about that and i chosen both. It is hard to decide. posted più di un anno fa.

	tosha112 picked film: I love the books as much as the movies. There should have been an option for both. posted più di un anno fa.

	green79 picked book: The books are amazing. posted più di un anno fa.

	LightningWolf picked book: Definitely the books, although the films were amazing as well. posted più di un anno fa.

	ChibiKashipan picked book: The films were a little boring.. And the books were AWESOME!!! posted più di un anno fa.

	London picked film: Ofcourse the books are fabulous but the films were a tad bit more memorable. posted più di un anno fa.

	_DarkPhoenix_ picked book: Very hard choice. posted più di un anno fa.

	weaslyismyking picked book: Some dry spots but I still enjoy them better than the movies. The movies are brilliant though, really the only book-to-film adaptation I like. posted più di un anno fa.

	ellie_bellie135 picked film: Oooooo!!! That's the exact same cover art as mine! The special volume :) I haven't read the books yet tho. posted più di un anno fa. last edited più di un anno fa

	dixiegirl96 picked film: i havent read the book so the movie i guess... posted più di un anno fa.

	LOTR802 said: Cant choose i LOVE BOTH FUCKING COOL THEY ARE BOTH COOL THE CAST WRITERS PUBLISHERS ARE CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL posted più di un anno fa.

	staplesnout picked book: Damn, the book of course %) posted più di un anno fa.

	Tawnyjay picked film: Both. posted più di un anno fa.

	MythGal picked film: both posted più di un anno fa.

	faithinChrist picked film: I would say both, since there were things I liked about the movie better (Aragorn and Arwen's love story, the proper timeline of events, seperate plots more mixed) but also things I preferred in the books (Tom Bombadil, Frodo's character). posted più di un anno fa.

	octopusness picked film: im still reading the books so id have to say the movies :P posted più di un anno fa.

	Book-Freak picked book: The books are better beyond all comparison. Don't get me wrong; I adored the films and the extended versions made my year, but the books... The books are a literacy marvel, the descriptive language is beyond belief, the extensive mythology and ethic presented is incredible... I could go on and on. posted più di un anno fa. last edited più di un anno fa

	Stya picked film: When you watch the film, you live together with characters, you can feel with them. It is very beautiful, exiting film! posted più di un anno fa. last edited più di un anno fa

	jennipop22 picked book: Both are amazing, but I have to chose the books on this one because they gave me an expectation of the movies. I also thought that the movies weren't as explanatory as the books, yes J.R.R. takes a while to make a point, but he describes that point thoroughly in order to fill in any questions you might have. Again, both are SPECTACULAR, but I have to go for the books on this one. posted più di un anno fa.

	Zutgirl picked film: It just takes too much time to read the books through... posted più di un anno fa.

	girly43 picked film: they make the book better. yea, the director sometimes takes out some stuff but it's all for the better. :) posted più di un anno fa.

	TaurielSaerwen picked book: THE BOOKS ARE WAY BETTER IF HAVE NOT READ THEM YOU MUST! posted più di un anno fa.

	DaniMF picked film: I haven't read all of them, they are extremely good but movies are a masterpiece. posted più di un anno fa.

	StampyCatLOL picked film: The movies are so good….. the last one made me cry. posted più di un anno fa.