Twilight la saga Article: Harry Potter against Twilight(can we compare them?)

8

Harry Potter against Twilight(can we compare them?)

posted by FunSize123

Most reviews will compare one book to another, but some libri can not be comapred like Harry Potter and Twilight.Most people will argue that they are about the same things but i disagree.

The only comparison is that they each have a mythological refrence. Vampiri#From Dracula to Buffy... and all creatures of the night in between. and Wizards but other than that none.Twilight is più of a romance novel then a fantasy , it just has the mythological twist of vampires. Harry Potter is più the fantasy not the romance.

There are two completley different situations in both the books. the only comparison is that the main characters are trying to be killed. Again for different reasons and with different outcomes and situations. So why do people compare things that not only dont need to be compared but really can't be compared?

In Twilight the main charecters are fighting not only with the bad people, but other characters(Jacob). Harry Potter They are mostly fighting with the main bad person.In Twilight most of the charecters are fighting to get bella on their side. In Harry Potter they are fighting to keep him alive instead of choosing sides.

So in the end is it really worth the comparison?
te decide.

GingeReid, sasie_katje88 and 6 others like this

Nyssa Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeek!!

tneb4everr yes it is. T W I L I G H T 4 E V E R

thisfiasco_ There is absolutely no comparison. I'm a die-hard Twilight fan and I think the series is amazing... But Harry Potter will ALWAYS be first, in my opinion. Stephanie is no where near as good of a writer as J.K Rowling.

vhey_1105 twilight 4 3va

DefineDelicate I hate that Twilighters and Harry Potter feel the need to compare the two completely different things, why can't we just enjoy the books and go on? is it because both are best sellers?? honestly does that even made sense? your going to compare them because they sell well? this is the problem with Fandoms these days, we can never just enjoy the books that were given to us, i mean i Love Twilight, i really do, and i guess i can't say much because i've never read Harry Potter, but doesn't mean i'm not right, i'm not like saying Twilight is better, because i don't know, i just like to read it, and enjoy, and i find it annoying as hell that people always compare Twilight to Harry Potter, even people on E! do it, it's so annoying.

Lgtherunner I LOVE TWILIGHT TO DEATH!!! i'm obbsesed/addicted no joke...but i was with harry potter too, plus i think the fact that all my friends like twilight where i was a little more alone with hp is the main reason it's even close.... HARRY POTTER ALL THE WAY MAN.... but TWILIGHT TOO :) and like i like the first twilights better than the first harry potters, but overall harry potter wins man not that i think they should really be compared!!! ones a LOVE STORY... and the others like an ACTION book.... you cant compare!!!!

docterjones yep, i agree too, there is absolutly no comparison at all. marvy article by the way. :)

KathyHalliwell I'm with thisfiasco_

kimmycole_24 i LOVe both books so i get really annoed when all my friends talk about twilight being the est and whenever i bring up harry they are all like whatever! it doesnt matter if u like twilight u can like HP too, its not that hard!!

2

Bella's school Friends

added by emmett

3

twilight bio scene

added by bella219

3

Volturi

added by CrisRodrigues

Source: Cris.Rodrigues

2

broken leg

added by AdaLove

3

He's a tracker

added by cilldill

Source: da Priscilla

4

Rosalie HQ

added by alexajaye

3

hottie taylor lautner

added by hello93

6

Twilight il film

added by neeki

Source: http://twilightmomsforums.freeforums.org/tmi-report-officially-on-the-set-4-4-08-adds-p-15-23-t5259-

9

Twilight Set

added by neeki

Source: livejournal.com

34

My New Moon Script (fan made)

posted by okellies

I am a budding screenplay writer and wanted to write a script for New Moon. For lots of reasons. Mainly, to satisfy myself in case the real movie is not what I think it should be

I post frequently over in livejournal at the lion_lamb community and have postato it over there too.

here are links to my screenplay
link
link
link

This screenplay has some things different from New Moon. te will recognize many scenes I kept. te will notice some things that I have combined. te will also notice stuff of my own. This is all typical with any adaptation.

There are also hints of Eclipse in here and set ups for...