rispondi a questa domanda

Critical Analysis of Twilight Domanda

-Sigh- Am I just over-reacting?!

My best friend, Josie has just finished Leggere the Twilight Saga and she likes it, I don't mind that.. but ANYWAY. We were talking about the Jacob-Resenemee thing and she doesn't think it's sick o has ANYTHING to do with pedophelia at all. She was saying that "He's drawn to it.." and stuff. So I got really annoyed and saying that Twilight was making her insensitive to serious issues like that...

Now she's not talking to me.

Seriously, was I just over-reacting???
*
ur both kinda overreacting
kk99aa posted più di un anno fa
 Mrs-Grint posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Risposte

rachaelwsz said:
My cousins and I usually laugh over it when I talk about it. They usually agree with me. XD

After a while when it 'cools;, (a little consigli :) ) the successivo time te want talk about it, do it like a laugh off matter. I find it affective. Sooner o later, the message will get through somehow... And were te overreacting? Kinda. Chill. :]
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
Myf_1992 said:
I think there's a slight over-reaction on both your parts. But its true that there's something not quite right with Jacob/Renesmee, it has a hint of pedophilia to it. She is wrong to completely deny it, but I think that maybe te should have kept your cool and nodded along, and then explained più thoroughly your part. And her not talking to you, ll, what are te 5? that's just childish to blank a friend over a difference in opinion.

Sorry to offend either of you, just my personal opinion on the disagreement. =D
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
agreed
kk99aa posted più di un anno fa
*
Mmm...yeah I suppose. I did over react a bit... yes, we are in bodies of tweens but we have the mental age of a toddler. Just the way things go.. ;)
Mrs-Grint posted più di un anno fa
*
lol don't we all haha
Myf_1992 posted più di un anno fa
EliWarp said:
Actually, I totally agree with YOU. That is totally sick and wrong, a teenage "Shape-Shifter" (I seriously HATE Twilight, BTW) falling IN-LOVE with a BABY?!?!?! WTF?! It is pedophilia (gonna look that word up, I see it so much) and it's just gross. Your friend is insane, and if she won't talk to you, then it's her problem she thinks that Jacob falling for Rene (I call her that :) is "Okay" Geez. If she wants a good book, I recommend HP. There is actual growth in the characters, not just falling in Amore (more like lust) with a sparkly hot dude who thinks te "Smell totally yummy" (Gross, much?) So I agree with you. te are totally not overreacting. I actually heard of some Twilight fan who nearly drowned a Fifth Grader (That's a anno younger than me. I'm making sure I stay far away from TwiHards in Highschool :P ) who detto that Twilight isn't as good as people say it is. And, please, the sex scenes? I own the books, because my father felt bad I didn't have much to read after HP, and some idiot at the book store recommended it for 11 anno olds. A Vampire romance novel. And it's barely romance. The first book, got about 17 million people buying it for TS. Hp? They got 40-80 million (Can't remember the exact number) *Cue long whistle* In total, Twilight made 44 million reads altogether, while HP got 448 million reads altogether, which make the total for TS about the same as the first HP book. Different, much? So read HP! It will change EVERYTHING! (Oh, and P.S., people don't read PJO (Percy Jackson and the Olympians) because the movie wasn't all that good. But the books? Awesome! Not HP awesome, but still, AWESOME! So give those two a read, PLEASE?!?!?!?!?!) There te have it! Ah, that was good to get off my chest.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »