rispondi a questa domanda

Harry Potter Domanda

Alright, a dementor sucks out your soul, but te have a horcrux. Discuss.

Not a question. Just, what do te think would happen?
 LoveforSeverus posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Harry Potter Risposte

BlackHound said:
It means that the little shard of soul that's in the horcrux remains in the horcrux, and that's all you've got left. Good luck with that. ;)
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
What would happen to your soul-less body?
LoveforSeverus posted più di un anno fa
*
Well, from what I understand, once te have received the Dementor's Kiss, your body just wastes away. There's nothing left, te don't get up and sposta around, so te couldn't put the shard of soul back in. te would remain in a persistant vegitative state until that horcrux was destroyed, I imagine.
BlackHound posted più di un anno fa
*
I should add that even if someone could bring the horcrux to you, I doubt that the shard coul be put back into you. But yeah. PVS until the horcrux is destroyed. Belgian Bummer, man. >.<
BlackHound posted più di un anno fa
*
I agree, that's probably what would happen.
madtron134 posted più di un anno fa
LadyNottingham said:
First you'll have a very frustrated Dementor : "What ?! I have only a bit of soul, not a full, whole, intact soul !!! I'm gonna complain to the Ministry of Magic and the Director of the Azkaban Correctional Facility ! Grrr !"

For the rest, that's a mystery. Voldemort had been severely diminished but he still had a bit of soul in himself. For a soul-less body, no idea.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
lol te make me giggle sometimes chicky :)
Faith-Rulz posted più di un anno fa
*
That was the purpose of my answer because I have absolutely no idea of what to reply. However, the domanda was a good one and inspired me on the funny side. lol
LadyNottingham posted più di un anno fa
*
That's something Umbridge would say. Don't offend the Dementor XD
delamico posted più di un anno fa
*
oh yes, she's so mean. I'm sure some men would even prefer baciare a Dementor than her. Well, I'm sure the Azkaban Correctional Facility manager, o even the Ministry of Magic, can arrange that, for wizards desperate enough that do not wish to baciare our dear Dolores.
LadyNottingham posted più di un anno fa
ScarlettSeverus said:
From what I believe, te are still alive, but every shard of happiness in te has been sucked away and te are reminded of all the painful memories te have. So, I don't think te are dead, o your soul has been sucked away. I think just all your happiness has. But I dunno.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
kandii1230 said:
If a dementor sucks out your soul but u have a horcux, then technically te still have your soul.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
MasterOfFear said:
Maybe your actual soul would be removed from the body, while the horcrux (not really a soul, only a fragment of it) would remain.

But i don't think te would function like te still had a soul. te would probably end up in a catatonic state, as a vessel for the horcrux, with it being the only thing keeping your body from being a vegetable.It might twitch and jerk o have some of the horcrux's owners memories (the owner might see through the bodies eyes at times) Maybe if the original owner of the soul dies and all the other (if their are any) horcruxes were destroyed, the original owner might actually end up inhabiting what used to be your body and taking it as its own.

But that's if the dementor's baciare actually gets your soul, and not the foreign peice of another's.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
delamico said:
I think your body will live on just as that of those who don't have a horcrux. As for the other half of your soul trapped in an object... I would assume that it'll remain trapped there for eternity, o until somebody doesn't release it da mistake o on purpose to give te another go at life. Otherwise I don't think te could save yourself, because when Voldy did so his soul was free, not trapped. However, the whole theory of horcruxes implies that your bits of soul contained in a object can free themselves, otherwise there'd be no use of a horcrux. Interesting guess. I'd like to hear what JK would say for this.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
LunaNotLoony said:
If a dementor sucked out your soul, te would have no soul in that body, just your horcrux. Seeing as other killing doesn't damage souls, according to Hermione, that would probably mean that body would be unusable, but, with a horcrux, te could be a merest ghost, even less than Vapourmort, who's piece of soul in the body hadn't been destroyed, whenever as you're was forever lost...
So literally when Vapourmort was floating about, that was his soul with no body. We have a body with no soul.
I think to allow te to return the horcrux soul would somehow be allowed to replace the old soul in the body (making them moral), but someone else would have to do some complex magical procedure to put it into your body. I don't know how it would work, seeing as the horcrux soul is destroyed if it's container is, but it's probably possible.... I don't know.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
zanhar1 said:
.
select as best answer
 .
posted più di un anno fa 
GaiaBVGSR said:
I don't know what would happen with the horcrux, but I think Voldy would still have his soul, until the dementors would baciare him
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »