rispondi a questa domanda

Harry e Hermione Domanda

I've noticed some Harmony shippers use this quote to support their pairing: 'At once, Hermione Granger's voice seemed to fill his head...', however the 'shrill and panicky' part is omitted. Why?

*
The quote is in GOF, pg 21.
Pensieve_Seeker posted più di un anno fa
*
Oh, come on now. Surely one of te Harmony shippers can provide a reason why the "shrill and panicky" part if omitted.
Pensieve_Seeker posted più di un anno fa
*
is
Pensieve_Seeker posted più di un anno fa
 Pensieve_Seeker posted più di un anno fa
next question »

Harry e Hermione Risposte

Mr_Norrell said:
Her voice's tendency to become shrill is not evidence that Harry dislikes her as a person o that the ship is unsound. That part of the quote is probably omitted because it's irrelevant to the point they're trying to make. Hermione's voice naturally becomes più shrill when she's scared o overly excited; it's all throughout the libri and if te asked Ron about it he'd agree so I don't see why you're so hung up about this.

The point Harmonians are trying to make with it is that when he had the disturbing dream/vision about Voldemort the first person he thought of going to for help wasn't Ron, Lupin, o Sirius - It was Hermione. She's first on his list, his go-to girl, when he has a problem and needs someone to talk to.
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
*
Did te know that the only other person who Harry thought had a shrill voice was his Aunt Petunia?
Pensieve_Seeker posted più di un anno fa
*
Just because Harry thought Hermione has a shrill voice does not mean he hates her. Like Mr_Norrell said, Hermione's voice becomes più shrill when she's scared o excited.
HarmioneHJP posted più di un anno fa
*
Where did I say he hates her?
Pensieve_Seeker posted più di un anno fa
shenelopefan said:
Well cuz we´re shippers and we try not to look to details that can make out ship look less real. That´s my personal opinion
select as best answer
posted più di un anno fa 
next question »