Is Johnny Depp's mad hatter better then disney's mad hatter?

I Amore Tarrant to death, and Johnny Depp is my hero, but I'm not going to lie. I think that the 1951 version is unbeatable. Johnny Depp comes VERY close, I Amore Tarrant but...the animated version was simply much more...muchier. He was random, unpredictible, and in general, MAD.
There was no knowing what he was going to do, say, and act upon. That's how the MAD Hatter is supposed to be, yes, Tarrant BECAME mad. I understand that...but in Underland....you don't need a reason. te just ARE.
Besides, te can't beat the awesome Citazioni that he has;

"Sugar!?? Oh! Yes, TWO SPOONS! Yes, *Grabs 2 spoons* ...yes, two spoons"
"Mustard, yes that'll.....MUSTARD?!?!? Don't let's be silly!! ...now LEMONS, that's...that's DIFFERENT."

"MOVE DOOOWWWWNN!!"

"My C-A-T..." "TEEAAA?!?!?!"

"TODAY, is my UN-Birthday!!"

I like it better. Disney's Hatter was cruel and sarcastic, I didn't really like it. But Depp's Hatter is much kinder, although much madder and crazyer in some way. He's a darker but lovelier character for me.

YES! Or... maybe not... I mean, Disney's Mad Hatter was freaking funny, and Johnny Depp's was più like... idk... more... serious... still, he had his funny moments... & he has better clothes.. (:

To be honest,i never liked the Disney animated version of the hatter. i mean come on!!! short little guy, with an annoying voice and who's so irreversably brainless....
Now, Johnny's version was a lot più interesting,complex mabye....and i agree that his clothes were much better.and he has mood swings too :)

Hellz yeah! The Johnny Depp one has a sexy and funny, and romantic vibe to him! I Amore him!!!
~B

in my opinion the new mad hatter is way better then disneys mad hatter of course thats just my opinion.

ehh i think they kinda did an overload on johnny's makeup and they kinda made him a lil to mad i think but other than that i think that johnny is better <3

YES he was a better Mad hatter but not quite as funny as disney´s but I may anyway prefer jhonny depp's mad hatter as the best!

Duh!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yes! Absolutly Yes! I Amore Johnny Depp!

Yea! He's Johnny Depp!

Ehhh... are te serious... OH COURSE HE IS!

ABSOLUTELY!!!!!